- bring back downvoting81% (21)79% (31)80% (52)Vote
- get rid of upvoting and downvoting4% (1)0% (0)2% (1)Vote
- keep just upvoting15% (4)21% (8)18% (12)Vote
I actually really like the downvote function.
A bit of a random example, but let's say someone asked the question "How do I look?" and then someone makes an incredibly racist comment that happens to not get hidden (I've seen em plenty of times before). Normally, in old GAG, that would be downvoted to oblivion for just reasons and there would be maybe 2 or 3 people with similar prejudiced mindsets who agree.
In new GAG format, all we can see would be the likes and comments. Hardly anyone ever wants to comment and start a fight with people, so people (like OP) would see the racist comment and the 2-3 upvotes/likes. That's like saying that the racist people are right in what they said and condones their behavior.
Let's say someone asks a question like "Does she like me?" Then, a user comments and decides to totally give awful advice to his question. Normally, people would read the bad advice and downvote, sometimes commenting. There would be maybe like 2 upvotes from people who thought the opinion was funny or are just trolling and upvoting to screw with people. Now under 18 OP is going to see the awful advice and be like "oh wow I guess this is what I need to do" considering the upvotes.
Yeah, these are possibly specific/outlandish examples, but to say this couldn't happen now is a lie.
Considering the nature of this site-- advice, downvoting is necessary. This, at the heart of it, is not a social media site like Facebook. Being able to agree or disagree with certain opinons/comments/questions is dire importance to an advice website such as this. It tells what opinions are good and what opinions are bad. Looking at only upvotes does not give an accurate representation of good and bad.
I appreciate the effort of GAG for trying to bring updates to the site. Some of them have been really nice actually. The "like" feature for questions is good in my opinion. But the downvote abolishment is quite bad. It is turning it into Facebook, and GAG should definitely not be like Facebook.
I want it back too. I very very rarely downvote, but I liked that option.
I like it this way, keeps dumbasses for downvoting unnecessarily. Now if you really got cojones you can just straight up tell the person why you disagree, but we all know that rarely happens.
I'm waiting until marriage for sex... Downvote, like really? This is for those who would downvote my opinion but can't 🖕🏽😜
Exactly. It makes no sense what do ever to get rid of one but keep the other. This sites already going down the drain, but I guess they're making sure it reaches the bottom in a more timely fashion
I agree, reason why this is better than fbl ol
While I agree with you, a lot of sites, like Youtube and Disqus have done away with downvoting, I think to spare hurt feelings and upvote/downvote wars. Facebook was said to be coming out with a Dislike button, but that never happened, did it? I just don't see it coming back as that seems the be the direction the tide is going with many sites.
Now I don't know if my trolling is working
Keep me happy! (: Upvote!
I definitely want down voting back
I want it back too!
Yes!!! I remember when Yahoo! Answers did this and it only lasted for about a week or so. I think it's way too politically correct and down votes can kind of help in a way (say someone asks for advice and someone is either trolling or giving horrible advice that is guaranteed horrible results), because they can kind of give the asker an idea of whether or not that really is a good idea, if you get what I'm saying.