I find that it depends on the situation.. But the longer the question (more detail) I find that the answers aren't that accurate because people think in black & white a lot on here. Like oh, some dude isn't behaving ___ way, dump his ass! He isn't interested! You deserve better! I know it's opinions and whatever, but I feel like many users don't fully read the question, misinterpret the information since its online, or have a one sided mind depending on how badly they've been burned by the opposite sex.
23% (5)18% (4)20% (9)Vote
14% (3)14% (3)14% (6)Vote
It's a hit or miss, the answers are all over the place
Well, I think you are right when you said that posts which are long with lot of details may not get accurate replies and one of the reasons I think is because of the length of the post, and not many people would like to read long questions, posts so they might start coming to conclusions mid way down the post, without reading it completely, and when they give their reply while doing that, the reply naturally will not be accurate.
I believe I always give the most logical and accurate suggestions, opinions but then sometimes even I can be wrong, I am also a human after all.
I will tell you what is happening - People don't read the question details often just answering the question title they see on feed or at best just skimming the details - I often see cases where that has blatantly happened.