What can I say to hit it off with this guy?

Anonymous
so I have this friend that I grew up with that plays baseball in college... he wanted to introduce me to a guy who plays in the major leagues that's really cute. so I met him at my friends apartment and we talked about fantasy football. a couple days later I asked my friend what the guy thought of me and he said I was really cute. I decided to forward things because the guy didn't have my number or anything. so I sent him a message on facebook and said "you had a really nice smile" and he responded sayin thanks and said somethin about being tired that day and then we got on the subject of fantasy football again. we were kinda playin hard to get, like waiting so long to respond back. then after messaging for a week he asked for my number. I sent it and got a text message the next day! Everything seems to be going good, right? only problem is we don't really have anything to talk about now! I have a sense of humor and I can be really outgoing but I'm stumped on this one! I don't know how to juice up the convo ? [[by the way, he's my age and he's seems to be a relationship kinda guy, that's really sweet and my friend said that this guys looking for a girl, not just a hookup girl]]

any suggestions on conversations I could bring up, or something I could say to hit it off a little more? we both act interested in each other but I want to seem more irresistable and fun!
What can I say to hit it off with this guy?
8 Opinion