Can you treat a girl TOO well?

Tech21
OK long story short...met a girl at my party we really didn't know each other I was older went to same high school blah blah. I guess I had a big rep when I was a senior as being a bad ass ( but its just cause I look like a toughy played sports and nobody knew me ) I kinda always knew I had this rep and liked it but

anyway I started actually talking to this girl her and her boyfriend were fighting so I kinda moved in. I got her number and we began to hang she even broke up with her boyfriend. as we started hanging I guess she got to know me and I remember her saying everybody thinks your so tough but ur really just a softy and smiled I thought that was a good thing but maybe not. anyway I was always so nice treated her so great and out of nowhere she couldn't hang out anymore ( when high school started she was a senior I went to county college ) she didn't really text me as much and she got weird so I called her out on it finally when I found out her and her boyfriend got back together... now she never even told me this or never said it was over. she replied by saying I thought you knew...

anyway we have been on and off ( the same thing happens every time ) for one year.. what's going on? was she attracted to the bad boy she thought I was, or did I treat her too good? I don't think her Boyfriend is a bad boy at all, although she did tell me he would make her cry a few times( like when I first met her ) so what is it? can you really treat a girl too good? or is she just fuxcked up please if you need me to clarify tell me.
Updates
+1 y
we never dated but we were together
Updates
+1 y
i forgot to mention this is very important I started seeing another girl, one that she claimed to have brought to a party for me, and me and that other girl hooked up ( because we were kinda in our "off part of our relationship and this time were friends
Updates
+1 y
girl a this first girl texted me saying she cried over me hooking up with girl b and how she's an idiot for not realizing it sooner how much she liked me and cherishes me blah blah so like an idiot I stopped talking to girl b and maybe 3weeks
Updates
+1 y
maybe 3weeks later girl a did the same thing, got weird couldn't hang stopped texting me... I don't understand
Can you treat a girl TOO well?
2 Opinion