She was just a little bit too fat before, but she's definitely too skinny now. Based on her weights (before 70kg, now 50kg) I'd say her ideal weight should be around 60kg.
by the way, if you use metric system (like the rest of the civilized world does :) ) it's quite easy to get an approximate value for your ideal weight. You take your height in cm (this girls is 170cm) and then subtract number 110. The result is your ideal weight in kg (in her case it's 60kg, just as it is evident from pictures). However, it's just an approximate.
pretty sure 154 qualifies as overweight... though in my opinion, slim her would look best with just a couple pounds more, like 5, 7 pounds.
A rational answer from @rationalmale. I think a lot of people will agree with you
why, thank you.
Wow that's like around my height, and I can't even imagine being 50 kgs. At 55, I look extremely thin and I cannot go below that at all. I think between 55-59 would be ideal for her height and weight.
When you put 2 pictures of the same person at different weights, the skinny picture becomes kind of.. I don't know, sad? If it was a picture of two different girls standing together (with these bodies) I think the poll would have got different answers.
They are both unhealthy and a fat girl can be curvy also a skinny girl. And both of them look awful.
The first one looks way better and healthier. The protruding bones are gross and don't look healthy.
Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions
What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!There's nothing wrong with being skinny but I think you have a problem when your ribcage is poking out... It just screams anorexic!
I like it when all the curves are clearly cut and outlined, so I go for skinny every time.
Okay... I guess I'm neither curvy nor skinny. 😐
The first one looks better, in my opinion. The second one lookd like she's going to faint
Well that's not curvy. That's just fat...
Yeah I know but let's face it most girls who have that figure will call themselves curvy!
^true shit! I slute you.
Curvy. The skinny girl in that picture needs to start doing something because she is way underweight.
The one on right is anorexic and malnourished
if its only between these two, id go with curvy, but something in the middle of these 2 would be perfect
how about somewhere in the middle.
Agreed. The left one looks off to me, and the right one just makes me feel damn right uncomfortable to look at. A happy medium between the two would be 👌 ace.
@linkywinky totally! you are right in the middle babes :)
I prefer athletic girls, but skinny is ok too.
In this case, the skinny one does not look healthy at all.
Curvy.. the other one is too skinny
Skinny would be good, but not this kind - she looks unhealthy. She needs to put on some muscle and probably some fat, too. I think she looks better in the picture on the left, but I would prefer something inbetween.
Neither is bad though, just my suggestion.
she doesn't look healthy?
I like both
Please, eat something... it's not healthy for you to weigh 111lbs... And while I'm sure it was hard, I like the 154 more...
I love skinny women the most. I'm a skinny man myself so I want a woman who is close to my size.
i want too feed her
Left one too curvy, right one too skinny, but I picked the "curvy" one because at least she doesn't look like she has a health problem. If she's 170cm tall she should be 60kg, and she went from 70 to 50. She should have stayed in the middle.
I like a mix off the both depending on the girl and the time.
I think she looks the best curvy. She looks almost malnourished on the right picture.
Sexual Relationships 
Sexual Health 
Most Helpful Guys