Most Helpful Guy
You have the natural attractiveness needed to pull off no make-up, and a lot of guys prefer that, so I would probably suggest going without make-up in general. That lets you then 'escalate' your looks for an important night out, for a fancy party, or formal events... things like that. If you have a lot of make-up on all the time, it becomes harder to crank it up a notch for special occasions without it seeking like overkill.
Think about it like a fancy dress... sure you look great in the dress, but you don't wear your best party dress every day - it ceases to be special. Consider make-up the same as clothes. You look nice without it, so without it should be your typical state. Sometimes add a bit if you want to look a little special, sometimes do it right up if you have a really special occasion. It gives you a lot more flexibility. Take advantage of your natural good looks.2