So I asked a question a few days ago asking if I looked overweight and a picture of me was included. One girl responded saying Yes you are extremely overweight. You should be about 110 pounds. I can tell because of these size and lack of definition in your calves. For one, I have extremely defined calves and they are almost entirely muscle with a 1/4 inch of fat near the hamstring. I'm 15 and recovering from anorexia. I'm still growing. So I argued back. And she made me feel like sh*t about my body and I starved myself for a day until I realized it wouldn't get me anywhere. So who was right, me or her?
- She is 100 percent right and you should lose weight.8% (1)25% (3)16% (4)Vote
- She's wrong. Stay the same or gain more.92% (12)75% (9)84% (21)Vote
Most Helpful Guy
I'm 5'3 and in just 52kg. According to BMI I would be overweight if I'm over 64kg. I'd be underweight if I'm under 47kg. So practically I'm in the normal weight just like you. But BMI doesn't really tell a lot. If you wanna know you're really overweight you have to know your body fat %. Usually I'm a 17 with 54% muscle mass. For girls its reasonable if your body fat is over 20%. If possible, can you post a pic of you again? I believe you are definitely not overweight. We have the same height, so same BMI.0