Most Helpful Guy
Top. But both are still good.0
Most Helpful Girl
I think your eyes look bigger when you line just the top lid.1
I think both ways look good but my vote goes to the second picture (which I guess is the one where your eyeliner is only on the top).
Bottom for sure
You look great in both
I would say just the top. Some women look like raccoons when they use too much eyeliner.
Both look really good but I recommend just the upper part. It makes your eyes look wider. :)