Right out of the shower. Should I dump her?
Most Helpful Girl
Here is my advice to you and I'm going to be straightforward. If you feel like you don't have feelings for her, disheartened by her real face, think she's not hot, please avoid her. Don't hurt feelings. Never ever ever sugarcoat anything you don't like. It might cause big trouble as you go along. Why would you even be with someone you're not interested with? Ask yourself, what's the main point in having a healthy relationship? What are the things you're thankful for in a relationship? Sure beauty can do the job, but would it be the same of what matters in the person itself?5
Most Helpful Guy
She looks alright. Maybe a little younger than 17. Anyway, why are you asking us if you should dump her by letting us see her look without makeup? That should really be your decision and no one else's opinion should matter or make a difference. You have to know how a girl looks with and without makeup. Not being the best you could wish for shouldn't mean you need to dump her. If you like her personality and for who she is then you should not be having thoughts about dumping her. And if you are more attractive than her, it doesn't mean you chose the wrong girl. Doesn't make you look like a bad chooser or whatever.2