1. dark lips and dark eyes
2. winged liner and lashes only
3. dramatic eyes (Katy price inspired look)
4. No makeup at all
Most Helpful Guy
4 looks best. if you wanted to go for makeup i'd say something like 1 but less of it or at least softer tones. you're really naturally beautiful so i don't think you want any makeup to distract from your features but only to compliment or slightly accentuate1
Most Helpful Girl
Are people still doing the duck face? I gotta be honest, it looks terrible, sorry. (The duck face, not you) You should just embrace having small lips and not try and push them out, it would look 10x better.
With that out of the way, number 4. You look great without makeup, you should try a more natural subtle makeup look because the rest look too overdone. It's like you have the extremes of both, heavy makeup and no makeup, your best look would prob be somewhere in the middle of that. Over doing your eyes takes away the natural beauty of them. You have really pretty eyes and I notice them the most in the last photo.
I even go a little Gung ho on the makeup too, sometimes it's hard to guage on your own face when you're going too far. I think number 3 is the best heavy makeup look (for a night out type thing)2