Me and my ex have been apart for a year and 6 months now. Yesterday she texted me asking me if she gave me the engagement ring back, as she been looking for it. So I told her she did give me it back, but she asked me if she could have it back. I asked her why, and she said because she thought it was hers. I just don't understand why after so long she's just asked me out of the blue. Plus I don't understand why she's asked me as she's seeing someone now and she knows how much the ring means to me.
Most Helpful Girl
It's not hers, it's yours, so she is not entitled to it.
Even if you had asked her to marry you and given it to her, an engagement ring is a contract, not a gift. It's given to a person under the condition that they will marry you. If the marriage is called off, the person is not entitled to keep the ring, it should be returned to the person that bought and gave it.1