This isn't the typical "makeup vs. no makeup" question. Obviously most guys are going to prefer a girl who's a natural looker over a girl who wears as much makeup as a stage performer.
This question is making you choose two different options using the same hypothetical girl. Picture an average-looking girl (whatever "average" is to you). Option A is that the girl prefers to wear very minimal makeup.
Option B is the same average-looking girl, but with additional makeup---not dramatic or dark "evening" makeup, nor totally invisible makeup that you can't tell she's wearing---just makeup that enhances her features. Makeup that does what it's SUPPOSED to do---make a girl look even better than what she does without it.
In MY opinion this girl's natural vs. made-up pictures are the most accurate example of the two options I'm giving you (but of course you may not share the same opinion as to what average-looking is)
- Option A, average looking girl36% (21)
- Option B, same girl but made to look above average64% (37)
Most Helpful Guy
I have expressed my dislike for makeup on GAG before and have gotten plenty of hate from the women here. None the less I will say it again, no makeup over makeup any day for me.
Yes of course I won't deny that the girl in the second picture looks great, but the fact that it's all fake takes away from the prettiness for me so I would go for A.
And I'm not saying this to appease women who don't wear makeup or to sound like a mangina. I legitimately dislike makeup and would appreciate a woman without it far more than a woman with it.0