Do you think female sex offenders should have their vaginas and clitorises cut out?

[Nathan-Vargas]

I've seen multiple polls asking if they think male rapists should have their penises cut off, nearly all women and even some men agreed that it should be done. Well what do you think about the same punishment for women? Or does this only apply to men, whereas women are poor victims who need our help to get better? I'll bet not a single person will think women should get this punishment, in fact most answers will say how appalling and sick the very idea is.

[kheserthorpe]

No.

There's also no reason to cut the penis off male offenders.

What actually might make sense in some cases is to castrate (that means testicles not penis) violent offenders who are otherwise treatable. The goal isn't to maim, its to permanently plunge testosterone levels. I would never advocate this as a punishment, but I actually DO think it should be considered as a possible elective course of treatment. We are currently (rightly) holding some dangerous offenders in prison indefinitely (i. e. till they're dead) because they are not safe enough to release. If they choose to electively undergo physical castration (which again is referring to testicles) which would crush their sex drive and allow them to re-enter the community, that seems like the best of a bad situation.

Removing the clitoris of a woman does not change her hormone levels, and I suspect would leave her more, not less likely, to commit sex offences.

I'm not sure if there's a 'relatively' simple physical method of dropping sex-arousal linked hormones in women.

[Nathan-Vargas]

You are sick in the head.

[Nathan-Vargas]

You almost remind me of those Joseph Mengele types of concentration camp doctors.

[kheserthorpe]

Thanks for the well thought out reply.

[Kaneki05]

Tbh nethier need it just lock them up no need to do that to ethier genders or just give them a death sentance for all i care but no point doing sonething so pointless it wouldn't stop them thinking the way they do.

[Ladyegg67]

I said yes just because a male sex offender will never get his junk cut of so women don't have to worry about it either. The question is just hypothetical, but maybe burning the area instead. The uterus can be removed but the vagina is mussel and tissue to be removed would likely cause death but removing are cutting will not stop a female rapists. She still can use her hands to insert objects into a man. You don't need a vagina to rape a man.

[Anonymous]

I'm trying to figure out how that's possible for the vagina. As for the clitoris, the point of castrating the penis is so that he can't rape again. Women don't rape with their clitorises. A woman could rape just as easily even if she had no clitoris

[MaskedSanity]

In general I think that's sick.

Buy if we advocate for male castration, then female castration should also be in place.
It's only fair.

[Nathan-Vargas]

Damn straight Male sex offenders are already being chemically castrated, it's an actual law put into place. Who knows when they'll upgrade to penectomies in the future.

[MaskedSanity]

Is that in the states?

[Nathan-Vargas]

Yes, as well as many European countries.

[MaskedSanity]

I don't think cutting everything off would pass the Geneva convention, to be honest. But if male sex offenders get chemically castrated, then women should get their tubes tied or something too.

[Nathan-Vargas]

Funny thing, female sex offenders don't. I remeber there was one European country where the chemical castration of male sex offenders was proposed, the parliment then asked the people who wrote the law if female sex offenders would get the same punishment, the answer was no. So the parliment laughed and the law did not get passed, at least for the moment. However in many other countries this is not the case.

[MaskedSanity]

Well, I can understand why. The majority of rapists unfortunately are still men, no mater how you try to spin it. Try to look up rape stats by gender and it will always be in favour of men. Female rapists exist, no question there. But not as many as male ones.

[Nathan-Vargas]

That doesn't make sense. You can equivalently advocate to cut off the arms of black shoplifters, but not white shoplifters, because the majority of shoplifters are black.

[MaskedSanity]

I'm not saying it's right, I'm just pointing out why it may be that only male offenders are being punished.

[Amagi82]

Mutilation is not acceptable punishment for any crime.

[Nathan-Vargas]

Unless the rapist is a man

[Amagi82]

No. It's not.

[LastGirlScout]

I think doing that to someone is sick, just as I think the idea of doing that to men is sick. Mutilating people is not fucking cool no matter what the reasons behind it are.

[MoonMice]

Yep. Agreed.

[Longblackveil]

I don't think either ones deserve that I'd rather give them the death sentence than that

[Cartouk]

If we're gonna as far as genial mutilation some backasword3world mob justice shit why don't we just go all the way and death penalty

[UlsterScot]

No just jail time.

[evenlift]

I oppose all punishments that cannot be compensated for. I do not support corporal or capital punishment for any crime, regardless of the identity of the criminal.

[FallenRangerz]

If males get that treatment so should women too, I mean it's only fair. I'm sick of all these BS equal rights crap when their not even actual equal rights.

[kangy]

Nope shouldn't

[lexih2146]

lol how would you cut out a girls vagina? but, yes female rapist are still rapists, they deserve the same punishment as men

[MoonMice]

I oppose this as much as I oppose castration of male sex offenders.

[bubbletrouble]

No. That's just sick.

[Anonymous]

Only if they do the same to guys.
Are you up for it?

[Anonymous]

Or they should be raped themselves? Itchin powder up their whohas would work too.

[Anonymous]

i believe that a rapist whether it was a male or a female should get punished but i just don't believe in female raping... i know i will get a lot of hate but i am saying what i can see... maybe a woman can rape a male child but she can't rape an adult man maybe unless if he is drunk or something

[Anonymous]

Dude, how would they even cut a vagina out? lol but no seriously, I don't think it is a necessary punishment for either gender. Just as long as they are detained and locked up and justice is served.

[Anonymous]

a penis can go inside a vagina
a vagina can't go inside a penis

duuuuuh !