Is spinning the bottle game cheating, my boyfriend broke up with me?

Were both 21 and I have been with my boyfriend for 2 years and everything has been great. Last week I went to a party with college students and they were playing spin the bottle and I played and kissed 4 guys and 3 girls. I'm not gay by the way, I'm 100% straight but the rules of the game were that if you are a woman you have to kiss whoever it lands on no matter if they are a guy or a girl. But if you are a guy and it lands on another guy you don't have to do it and can spin again till it lands on a girl. Not sure why the rules were like that but it was. I'm 100% straight but I woudn't mind making out with a girl if I was drunk enough or if she was hot enough just for fun haha Anyways I ended up kissing 4 guys and 3 girls, it didn't mean anything, it was just a game. When I told my boyfriend he got upset, hurt, and I tried explaining to him that it was not a big deal, that it was just for fun. He claimed I cheated on him, he said he would never do that to me. He also said "what if I became a porn star, had sex with woman and claimed, it doesn't mean anything, its just doing my job" and he started saying "what are you now bi, how do you kiss a gender for fun even though you are not atracted to them" and I tried explaning its not impossible and that and even thought I'm 100% straight, I woudn't mind making out with a girl if I was drunk enough or if she was hot enough just for fun and that made him angrier and said that I was a immature child, a sorority cunt and he broke up with me and left. He also said the very least I should have done was tell him before actually doing it so that way he could have made a decision on whether or not this is something he tolorates, its just that I never thought it would be a big deal to bring up. When I asked him why didn't he ever ask me where we stood on kissing other people he said "well geez, i dont know, it just seemed like commn sense that kissing another person che
Updates:
+1 y
Continued... When I asked him why didn't he ever ask me where we stood on kissing other people he said "well geez, i dont know, it just seemed like common sense that kissing another person cheating" Anyways he broke up with me, and I tried calling him, texting him and he changed him number, blocked me from facebook. Why am I wrong, I mean its just having fun, he has to live a little and stop being so jealous
+1 y
I would not mind if he was kissing another girl during spin the bottle, if he kissed a guy during spin the bottle that would bother me, because its weird. But yeah I would nto get jealous. And at least I was honest, it just goes to show you that being honest has consequences. He needs to grow up and smell the coffee. Maybe its because he's hispanic so he comes from a different culture, but if thats the case he needs to let go of his traditional latin culture, its America, let loose, GOD
0 0

Most Helpful Guys

  • Read all the comments, and I agree it the majority: you cheated.

    A couple of points:

    I've read a number of your responses to others where you said that your ex boyfriend should "grow some balls". What you really mean is that he should "shut up and take it". You want him to quietly tolerate your misbehavior. That is the opposite of growing some balls. You are just butt hurt that he defended his boundaries and left the relationship.

    Furthermore, your ex was not being controlling either. Controlling behavior would be if he remained in the relationship with you but demanded to never have you be out of his sight, or to never go anywhere without him. Controlling behavior would be cutting you off from your friends or telling you where you could or could not work.

    Your ex did none of that. What he did do was, like any mature adult, he defended his boundaries. He refused to be in a relationship with someone who did not value that relationship as highly as he did.

    Calling him a pussy for not happily rolling over and being your bitch is just sour grapes on your part. You just got busted with your hands in the cookie jar and so you are trying to rationalize your way out of it.

    Lastly, I don't see it that he broke up with you over the kissing game so much as the argument that followed it. He told you he did not like that you kissed others. At this point, if you had said you were sorry and that you did not understand that this was a boundary for him, he would have forgiven you. Alternatively, you could have said to him that you require more autonomy when in a relationship than he is willing to accept. If that was the case, you could have amicably broken up with him yourself. Either of the above approaches would have been superior to what you actually did.

    You demanded the right to violate his boundaries without consequence. Which is to say that you demanded he either eliminate his boundaries or change them to match yours. THAT is controlling behavior. He refused to be controlled by you.

    Actions have consequences.
    I thought adults knew that.

    • What he said ^^

    • Nailed it.

  • He's right, it's cheating. Just because it's a game doesn't mean it doesn't count. So what if the game says you gotta blow a guy off? What if you have to fuck him? Is it still ok cause "it's a game"?

    He's right, you sound like an immature guy, and good for him for breaking up with you.

    • I'm not a guy, and you are just being too sensitive

    • Maybe you're to stupid to see that my icon is pink and that represents females, and based on the context of what I wrote you should have figured that out. And sex is different than kissing, so no you suck at arguing

    • Couldn't agree more!

    • Show All

Most Helpful Girls

  • He is entirely right and it is you who needs to grow up.

    The fact that you didn't even consider asking him how he felt before you went out and sucked face with 7 different people speaks volumes about your character, or lack thereof, to be precise.

    "the rules of the game were that if you are a woman you have to kiss whoever it lands on no matter if they are a guy or a girl. But if you are a guy and it lands on another guy you don't have to do it and can spin again till it lands on a girl"

    You hang out with some interesting hypocrites, by the way. Your ex viewed your behaviour as highly inappropriate and rightfully so since the guys in that group got to make out AND get visual stimuli from watching girls make out in front of them.

    Ultimately, your ex doesn't owe you anything and bringing his heritage doesn't make an ounce of difference.

    I'd dump your sorry arse too.

  • I think that's rubbish, first off if you're 21 and in a relationship you shouldn't really be participating in a game like that, it's usually for singles. You did cheat on him because you did kiss other people, and so what if they were girls some guys aren't comfortable no matter what sexual orientation you are. You really were in the wrong, if roles were reversed you'd probably feel betrayed if he kissed other girls too. It's true if you're in a monogamous relationship with only each other, kissing people outside the relationship isn't going to be tolerated most likely.

    • I think also its the fact that you were so willing to kiss other people is what bothers him the most, he doesn't know where you'd draw the line.

  • Tbh this is considering cheating. Tap kiss or not. If your in a relationship then it is Common Sense to know it's not right to kiss other people while being in a relationship even if it didn't mean anything. Even if you guys didn't have a conversation on if it's alright to kiss other people it's still should've been something you should've known not to do. That's like saying "I had sex with another guy, my boyfriend broke up with me but we didn't have a conversation Wether if it was right or wrong if we could fuck other people while being together" lol.

  • I agree with your boyfriend. Kissing other people should be common sense not to do while in a relationship. Who caresnif it was a game? Like he said, you should have called and told him what you were going to do, or better yet, not play a kissing game in the forst place. I know its no fun.. but you chose to be in a relationship amd if you can't handle the boundaries, then be single.

    • And it has nothing to do with his latin culture lmao. My boyfriend is also hispanic. That has nothing to do with it. He just doesn't want his girlfriend to kiss other people and thats not so hard to understand.

    • Just saying I'm not dating Hispanics anymore, not going to deal with that latin-lover posse boycott crap, he can go back to Mexico if he wants a traditional girl. Whatever makes him happy I guess. American girls like me like having fun other ways and he's to into the whole overly romantic thing and being so traditional. Its just a kiss, I didn't fuck anyone

    • It's called being a normal person.

    • Show All

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls & Guys Said

11 31
  • Even just a kiss is considered cheating, of course not for a bitch like you lel (normally i don't offend someone easily especially on the internet but reading your comments to the other opinions was like, is she that dumb and ignorant.. ) So you cheated on him, he left you (I'm happy for him cause he found out soon enough what a stupid innocent girl you are) Oh and.. " he can always go back to Mexico and find himself a traditional girl." AHHAHAHAHHA Why the hell do you even post this question then.. ? Damn, i hope he does find a girl like that in Mexico! Good luck to your next boyfriend!

  • I can kind of see his point. I would not be comfortable with my boyfriend kissing another girl even if he was playing spin the bottle - He shouldn't be playing it in the first place!

    I do find it a little odd that you say you kissed some girls but would be uncomfortable with him kissing a guy.

    My advice would be next time you're in a relationship, discuss what you would both consider cheating and what you are comfortable with before doing anything.

  • You troll as shit, little boy. ^_^

    Just leave my country and Hispanics out of lame trawls like this. At least make it funny.

    s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/.../...bfbe9dc971.jpg

  • You could've asked him to come along at the party and would've been avoided all in all. Both parties approached the whole situation wrong. To me this game is really a petty reason to break a 2-year relationship, especially if that relationship has already created some strong history/bonds before it became a relationship. But then again, I'm a little wiser. I just might've acted the same way back then, but back then, I am not what you guys would consider a "boyfriend-material" kinda guy.

    You knew the rules would involved kissing and probably knew your boyfriend had some issues with it regardless if you kissed a man or woman. Sure its only a game. It has nothing to do with culture. More on how he views certain situations. You did right by telling him, which in turn, I wished he had given it some more thought before making a rash decision on the spot and throwing everything you two had built together in one swoop, but you also could've avoided this situation if you just hadn't played the games that involves someone touching you. You knew your ex for 2 years. In that 2 years you didn't see any possessive traits? 2 years is an awfully long time to get to know a person, especially in an intimate one.

    This situation really boiled down to personal views between 2 people. It had nothing to do with ethnicity or ethnic traditions/cultures.

    • How is that a petty reason to break up, some people take that seriously, no its not petty, and I would be upset. If you are ok with it thats you, if you can tolerate things, that all you, but that does not mean what he feels and how he responded to that was petty, he moved on and realized he won't tolerate it, he has different values. No petty at all.

    • @Stumpy_Cheetah Stop being a bitch ok, its petty deal with it.

    • @Gman77 this guy think the reason to break up was petty, and stump is being a bitch also

    • Show All
  • I think u need to reevaluate ur opinion on what constitutes as cheating. Regardless if it's a game or not, u kissed other people. That's cheating. Doesn't matter what the circumstances were. If ur in a relationship u shouldn't play spin the bottle. Unless u and ur partner have agreed beforehand that certain things are acceptable.
    And being honest is not a mistake here. If u hadn't told him he would've found out from somewhere else eventually. Honesty is always the best policy

    • No, you're wrong and you are being a over sensitive boy scout control freak, a kiss is just a kiss. Overly jealous and controlling.

    • To u that's what it is. But obviously to him a kiss means more. And it's not for u to decide what a kiss means to him. For me personally, I don't think I would've broken up cuz of that, but I would've said if it happens again we're through. Since in ur mind it sincerely wasn't any big deal I would've told u how I felt about and then if u did it again then bye bye. I think that's what he should've done but again, it's his choice. Obviously to him a kiss is very important

    • You're being over sensative if you would break up because of that, you're a control freak and overly jealous.

    • Show All
  • It's clear that you don't want a monogamous relationship. That's what he wanted and he had every right to leave.

    • Concise, and undeniably accurate. Good post.

    • @gray_sailor no need to point out stuff others have pointed out, is usually my motto on here. :)

  • Yeah, no, that's so not cool. Don't kiss other people when you're in a relationship. It's pretty simple.
    If I were him, I'd be pissed as hell. If my boyfriend did that, I'd hate it, and if I did it, he'd be just as upset.
    If you don't get that, you probably shouldn't be in a relationship to begin with, or at least find an open relationship.

  • Lol, you're really stupid.

    • no you are, get off your black pedestal, you're blind

    • Lol, my black pedestal? Are you trying to be racist or whatever?

    • Oh and I mean black pedestal as in a pedestal consumed by darkness, not because you're black, no racism intended but I don't want you to start randomely pulling out the race card since it seems you people like doing that and blaming me for white privilae or enslaving blacks, latinos or Native Americans, no thank you

    • Show All
  • If I ever saw my girlfriend kissing some other GUYS and GIRLS (even more than one wtf) and told me it was just because of a game, I'd immediately push the person away from my life. If you cannot see whats wrong with kissing other people while in a relationship, you are missing some common sense. This is a complete no-no.

    • Thank you!!! Couldn't agree more. (hint: I'm the person that brought her to school up top)... Lol.

  • Because you cheated on him. WTF? do you really not see that?
    what if he just walked down the street kissing the women? I don't think you would like it. I love when people cheat then try and blame it on other things. Oh, it wasn't me, it was the bottle. That MADE me kiss someone other then my SO.
    sorry babe, you chose to kiss other people. Man or woman, gay or not. But my guess is the guys are the issue. My ex once asked if she could kiss a friend once. I said only 1 x and I had to be able to watch. but not more then 1x and never without me present. Even that made me feel uneasy. Luckily she never did it.
    of course her fucking the woman's husband was more the issue but that happened later.

    • a girl friend?

    • female?

  • You did sexual things with many people without your boyfriend permission so it's still cheating as well as slutty, the game excuse don't worth much, you shouldn't play that stupid game in the first place.

  • I agree that is cheating i would never do that to someone i was in a relationship with its common sense do you want him kissing other girls?

  • "Why am I wrong..."

    You're wrong because you cheated on him. I don't understand how you're confused about this.

  • You definetely cheated, I just had a talk with my girlfriend because she was kissed by another guy and didn't set her boundary properpyl. You most definetly cheated according to me and this other user. Almost anyone besides an immature college student would find that as cheating. It's just common sense.

    • If he has a problem with the way us American girls like to have fun he can always go back to Mexico and find himself a traditional girl. I'm sick of his romantic latin-lover goody boy scouts behavior. He likes to play the victim. Also why are you going to let 1 kiss come between your girlfriend and you, you are being to limiting, why don't you learn to have fun. Life is short. Its not like she had sex, sex is different

    • I forgot to add how confused you are. You deserve every bit of what he has done, I recommend you seek professional help on how relationships should be. Perhaps talk to a counselor at your college or a therapist so you can get the help you deeply deserve. No one should be this confused.

    • Maybe you need to learn to be less jealous and stop being so sensitive. Maybe you should go to mexico and find a traditional girl also

    • Show All
  • they don't give a fuck if its a game lol. all they will hear is "i kissed 4 boys"

    and then they will justify it by calling you immature, like he did, for playing such a game.

    per your update, it doesn't matter if you don't mind if he kisses another girl, bro you have to take his thoughts and feelings into consideration, you're both in this relationship together.

    • Sorry but if it would bother you that your girlfriend kissed other guys in a game then you are nothing but a jealous control freak. Sorry to break it to you, if you want a traditional girl maybe go to mexico, thats where my ex probably is since his donkey latin ass wants traditional who will never kiss someone else while being in a relationship, never going to date a latin guy again

    • This is a pretty way of saying that the relationship meant nothing. Keep thinking this way, and the only guys that will have anything to do with you will be those looking for hook ups.

    • @Sabretooth My thoughts exactly

    • Show All
  • I'm hoping and praying this is a troll. If not, I feel sorry for you OP. You are in the wrong unless you are in an open relationship (which you clearly aren't), then what you did is considered as cheated. Your boyfriend or should I say ex boyfriend didn't agree to sharing you with other people. It's a game yes but my first thoughts would be '' i have a boyfriend so there are certain things I won't be doing ''. I would also openly tell the people I'm with so they understand that I love and respect my boyfriend, and I wouldn't do anything to hurt him. I would pass on kissing anyone male or female, why? Because it is cheating. I would dump any guy that did this to me. I hope you have learned something from this experience. Also, it's okay for you to kiss other women but if he kissed other men you would have an issue. You need to grow up.

  • When, if ever, he grows up he'll attend socials & dances where good friends kiss - it's high society european & world wide, not to mention Hollywood.

    Kissing can be intimate but also a parallel to
    I love you vs. bye, love

    The next level up is touching "private parts"

    Then of course, sex

    That's how removed you are from cheating.

    Now let's discuss the relationship
    has he proposed? Not even close to marriage?
    Then you are free to date and do whatever with whomever.

    Does he feel he has a master slave relationship and you wear a collar & leash?
    No? Then how are you breaking the rules?

    What IS this really about?
    HIS insecurity, HIS inability to compete with others, HIS lack of desire to step up the romance to assure a lock on this relationship.
    Instead, he does the lazy & distateful action of making YOU the bad guy (not him).
    If he usually turns the facts around on you, why would anyone want an eternal life with such a mentalist prison guard? He is not speaking words of love and understanding. He is speaking words of control, reform and making you feel bad about yourself (= hate).

    Although such a party may not be your cup of tea, it happens... often planned by a secret admirer or one wanting to break your boyfriend away so they can have a shot at you.
    You are free to live your life until you commit to the rules of marriage that often a couple can modify.

  • Its fine if you think its ok to kiss others. I mean swingers exist for a reason. But thats outliers and then you should find someone who accepts that. But dont be surprised if he has sex with another girl and tells you thats not cheating.

    At the end of the day, you did cheat

  • Well you had it coming.
    sanguines.files.wordpress.com/.../sense_cheats.jpg
    Sorry bro, all's fair in love and war.

  • Have to go with the general consensus and your boyfriend on that one... your a little old for playing those types of games when you supposedly in a relationship.

    I would see it as untrustworthy and likely cut you loose.

  • Show More (22)