Girls, we had threesome with my girl's ex and I want more! Should I tell her?

My girlfriend and I recently had a threesome with her ex! I know... "O. M. G" right? That is what I was thinking at first too. The thing is that we had been planning a threesome for awhile, this was MY fantasy and she said we could do it, IF it was with a GUY first. I agreed because, fair is fair. We tried looking online and quickly decided that we could not do this with some rando guy. We also quickly ruled out any of our friends because... awkward! She bumped into her ex one day and when she told me about it that night she joked that we could do it with him since he loved having sex all the time and would be up for anything. It was meant as a joke but we realized that they broke up on good terms, she trusts hims, knows he is safe, discrete and knows he is good in bed. She also knows that she feels nothing romantically for him at all anymore and doubts she ever really did. All they really had was good sex. So... it happened! Some highlights: Giving head is NOT as easy as it looks and can be awkward. Maybe because he was rather big and/or I was just nervous? I think I nicked him with my teeth because he pulled out and let her blow him. I licked his balls while she sucked him and they shifted positions so that his butt was right in my face while I was licking. I could see her through his legs sucking in front and that was SOO hot! I slipped from balls to asshole at one point and was stupidly hoping he didn't notice. He seemed to like it though and I really love doing this for my girl so since it was pretty much the same thing, I stayed there! It was SUCH a kinky thing to do I was getting hard. He didn't last long after that. We took a break, had some drinks and my girl wanted to see him fuck me. We played with a strapon before so I was ready. What I didn't expect was that a real guy/ real penis would be so much better than a girl with a toy. Later, he did it with my girl and I was amazed at how physical and intense they were. Just covered in sweat. (Continued)
Updates:
+1 y
(continued) So after it was over. We talked and she thanked me for being a good sport and that we could look for a girl threesome next (as long as it wasn't MY ex) That's a long story and I totally agree! The thing is, I just want to do it again with her and her ex! She's over it. It was an itch she scratched and that's enough. Me? I didn't expect to like it and loved it! I still prefer sex with girls and MY girl but this was an experience I'd like more of, ideally with him. Should I tell her?
0 2

Most Helpful Girls

  • I say yes. You guys seem pretty open about your wants and desires in this relationship, so that shouldn't be a problem! Just let her know you really liked it and you'd like to do it again because it was really hot, and just be open to how she reacts either way. She might say no, she might agree again, just ask.

  • So basically u r bigger and now have a crush on your gf's ex... well that escalated quickly

    • Bisexual^

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls Said

(1)
  • Yeah. Tell her.