Girlfriend wants a threesome...but with another guy! What should I do?

Joined this site purely to get a female perspective on what might be going through my gfs head lol.
Basically we have been in a relationship for 18 months (6 of which we were friends with benefits). I'm her first proper boyfriend, she's 24 and I'm 25 whereas I've had several relationships. We have roleplayed about theeesomes in the past but that was more my idea to get her off not expecting it to ever become a possibility.

She has always maintained, during conversations in the past that she could only have a threesome with another guy, she'd never be able to have one with another girl.
We have a healthy sex life although I work away in Toronto (3 hours away) during the week so only get to do it on a weekend.

Recently she has shown a lot more interest in having another guy, we talk about it (roleplay) a lot more than we use to and she now requests it. I talk about it because I know she likes it and I want to make her happy, the fact we roleplay about it doesn't really bother me.
I'm now wondering if I should consider maybe signing us both up to somewhere and introduce another guy for her?

Why all of a sudden is she more interested in having other men?
Could she possibly be bored of our sex life and fantasising about this to herself?
How would you recommend I'd deal with seeing her with another guy?
So many more questions going through my head, I just want to make the girl I love happy.
Updates:
+1 y
updates.
+1 y
Upsss
2 4

Most Helpful Guys

  • View Earlier
    Not talked about this with anybody else, lol, and not ready to discuss in public EVEN here, hahaha
    Sun, May 28 04:29 PM
    Do it anon
    Sun, May 28 04:30 PM
    Possibly. The male responses are VERY negative indeed.
    Sun, May 28 04:31 PM
    Well duh
    Sun, May 28 04:32 PM
    Meaning, lol?
    Sun, May 28 04:33 PM
    Predictable and in denial
    Sun, May 28 04:36 PM
    They would not like that, Cheerie, they really would not, lol

    Anyway, his questions are

    Why all of a sudden is she more interested in having other men?
    Could she possibly be bored of our sex life and fantasising about this to herself?
    How would you recommend I'd deal with seeing her with another guy?

    And I don't know the answers to any of this, either, hahaha

    I shall try anonly, however
    Sun, May 28 04:37 PM
    Lol ok. I won't waste my time
    Sun, May 28 04:38 PM
    Have a quick proof read

    It could well just be a fantasy. My girl has been quiet up until very recently about this, but it appears that lots of women do have this as a fantasy.

    It also doesn't mean she's bored of your sex life. She may just be interested in doing something different.

    As for dealing with seeing her with another guy, I can't help you with that one, I truly cannot.

    Ultimately, it is up to you as to whether you take this any further, as it doesn't sound as if she's holding a gun to your head about it. It's good that she trusts you enough to communicate openly, though.

    There are clearly a lot of other posters on this thread who wouldn't engender that kind of trust.

  • Fuck that, she wants a threesome? I would walk away from the relationship and say go fuck the dude for all I care. If a guy even said that to his girlfriend, like yo can your best friend come sleep with us and I get to bang the both of you is ridiculous.

    She doesn't seem to be serious at all for a long-term commitment in a relationship and it's more about her fulfilling her sexual desires. If you want to adore the ground she walks on go ahead, if you don't want anything serious either then sure go for it if you want.

    But I find threesomes a little screwed up, I found them to be sexy and funny at the same time when I was a teenager, now when I hear that shit I shake my head and think wtf?

    I know people will read my comment and give me a ton of thumbs down but I don't give a fuck, I am not on this site for the sole purpose of others simply agreeing with some idiotic.

Most Helpful Girls

  • She loves you, threesome is just a fantasy lol.

    Being centre of attention feeling many men love her and adore her. It gives a lot of power to the woman.

    Maybe she wants to feel what double penetration or giving blow job to another guy while having sex with you feels like.

    I doubt it means anything more than a fantasy.

    I mean what woman wouldn't want to be pleased in bed by many men who love her? It's a very common fantasy.

    It's really up to you... how jealous you are lol to allow it. If you feel like you will regret it, just keep it as roleplay and maybe by a dildo or something so you can do double penetration :-)

    • Buy******

    • I'm guessing you been in an orgy before

    • @Hassaniscool lol I wish

    • Show All
  • I'm like her, I could do it with two guys, but not with another girl. My boyfriend understands and is OK with that. If it doesn't seem fair to you, then don't do it. She'll understand because it just makes sense. Don't talk about jealousy and crap, just say it's not fair and be done with it. If you can get past the unfairness, then let her have her fantasy. She will love you for it. Many women would envy her for having a great guy like you.

    • I fear that this will harm our relationship

    • If you get jealous or angry, then yes it could be a disaster. But that's all on your side of the deal. She's not going to leave you for the other guy. Why would she? Communication is key. Tell her that the idea turns you on, that's why you do the role playing. But tell her you aren't sure you could handle it. There are ways you guys can test the waters without going too far.

    • Have you done it threesomes?

    • Show All
  • If it would be the other way around with two women and her not wanting to bring another gal, all guys would approve of this treesome and talk shit about the girl who doesn't want to.

    Talk to her, she's prolly just fantasizing about it just like you are about other things for sure.

    • I don't fully agree. I would have a threesome with another man, not with another girl, in my relationship.

    • @guilly18butnot Well, you are in the rarity.

    • I know. However there's a big percentage of men who would not mind that much. Usually men with self confidence in bed and with a fulfilling past in sexual matters, comply with this. Also it is important that the relationship is very healthy in trust matters.

    • Show All

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls & Guys Said

16 45
  • Talk to her. Try and figure out why she wants to bring another guy in. Maybe she is just fantasizing about having two guys enjoy her body at the same time? Perhaps that's a turn on for her?

    It may not have anything to do with you and everything to do with her own sexual desires.

    Ultimately though, if you are not comfortable with the situation, then don't agree to it. Make sure you are fully comfortable before doing anything with another person.

    • I fear that this will harm our relationship

  • Well, it is better that she proposes this to you instead of cheating all along.

    She obviously finds your actual sexual life boring, or repetitive, or not exciting anymore, and wants to introduce new factors/actors to it. I don't mean that she does not find you sexually attractive or that she does not enjoy sex with you anymore, I mean that she needs new thrills to spice up your sex life.

    And you should be happy that she tells you instead of finding that thrill elsewhere. It proofs she respects you and loves you, and would like to share her sexual desires with you and not by herself.

    May you not be willing to comply, because you feel insecure about the view of her enjoying another man, then don't do it until you understand her desires and are in tune with them.

  • I am sorry to say but probably she's not that into you anymore and wants to experience :-/ do you live together? Maybe try and increase the intimacy you have? She probably has a high sex drive and just fantasizes about more :-/ but then again maybe im giving ill adivce since im not into threesomes :-/

    • Totally just made the chewbacca sound lol

  • be careful. You just said you only see her on weekends. You might be setting her up with a weekday option.

  • The thing about threesomes is both people have to be 100% on board with the idea. You can't go into it with any doubts otherwise it won't be fun and that defeats the purpose of the whole thing. By the sound of it, your girlfriend is bought in to the idea but you're not. So my advice would be to tell her how you really feel about it. If you don't want to do it, just say so. If she cares for you at all she'll understand.

    • Is it normal thing threesome?

    • Threesomes are normal. But both people have to be ok with the third for it to work. Had some with an ex because she was sexually attracted to girls too. It great. But I would have hated there being a third person, with a dick, I wasn't into. That makes it a gang bang.

    • I'd have to disagree. I don't think threesomes are normal but that doesn't necessarily mean they're bad. They're a lot of fun but again, only if EVERYONE is 100% on board

    • Show All
  • I'm not cool with the idea of threesomes in any arrangement.

  • Guys here have a problem with this general concept. It's not even worth trying to explain it biologically or emotionally.

    • And for good reason. Outsiders aren't supposed to be in a couples bed

    • @lord_chilled oh for fucks sake that's not what I meant. And obviously it's not for everyone bruh. ✌

    • Yeah im gonna go trump level ignorant on this one and say its not for anyone period

    • Show All
  • Maybe it was always something she fantasized about and since you brought it up she thought maybe you would be into trying with her.

    There is a chance she could be but you really should just talk to her about it rather than get in your head to deep about it.

    If you do decide to do it make sure you guys come up with a deal like if you aren't cool with it at any point everything stops.

    I really hope everything works out for the better.

    • You know that can destroy a relationship, right? How can you even fathom the thought of someone you are within a relationship that you love and care about to have sex with another person while being with your spouse? This is not about trying to compromise, the poster (being this guy) should END IT. How would you like it if you were with a guy you really loved and he said, let me fuck you and your hot friend, I don't know man, maybe it's the age difference you are 21, I'm 31... I'm pretty sure 10 years from now you would think there's no way in f-ing hell I am going to allow my husband to have sex with another woman in bed.

    • @thatguyfromtoronto I never said he shouldc ompromise I never even said try it for her sake. I'm trying to encourage communication between them. And of course it can ruin some relationships but it doesn't ruin all of them.

    • Stating "making a deal" is a compromise. Solution: End it and move on.

    • Show All
  • DUMP. HER. ASS.

    She's already fucking someone else (that's why the 'sudden interest'), she just wants you to approve and legitimize it.

    Instead, tell her to hit the bricks.

  • Do you really want to see another guy bang away at her? What if she enjoys it more than you? You are crazy if you do this.

    • Finally someone with some sense

    • agreed!

    • Sometimes i have a feeling you are the only female on this website who have a common sense

    • Show All
  • Be honest with her about how you feel about it. If she respects your decision and the relationship then give her the benefit of the doubt. If she cannot respect that, then you have to make that tough decision and break up with her. Otherwise, you will regret it and cause much stress for yourself.

  • This is what happens when you start pandering to your partners sexual fantasies at the expense of yourself. First of all the most important question is are you comfortable with it? Are you comfortable with the idea of her having sex with someone else even if you're involved? I know for sure that I wouldn't be but this is a question you have to ask yourself. If the answer is no then you need to tell her immediately that you're not ok with it. You honestly shouldn't have even started these roleplays if you weren't comfortable with it. Also you could easily call her out on her hypocricy of wanting a mmf threesome while being against the idea of a mff threesome.

    Either way there is no way to know what's gonna happen if you end up doing it, more likely than not she's gonna like it and want to keep doing and that's gonna change how your sex life is right now, of course there is also a chance that she's just curious and it would be a one time thing but I doubt that.

  • I can only tell you what I would do:

    Break up with her immediately.

  • maybe it gets her off: thinking of you and another dude getting her off while he is giving it to you as well. ever thought of that? it may not just be she wants anal and vadge filled same time...

  • This threesome is usually not a good idea when in a relationship. I'd advise against it...

  • I don't think it's all of the sudden. It's likely been in her mind before but by discussing it, she's felt more free about expressing her desires. When my wife and I started discussing it, she acted a bit hesitant but when she finally "warmed" to the idea, I found out she had the thoughts before but just didn't want to be the first to bring them up. Once we crossed that line, it was pretty easy for both of us to enjoy MFMs. You two need to seriously discuss the logistics, feelings, and potential ramifications before actually doing it, though.

  • Don't do it, if you aren't comfortable with it. Especially if she only wants it her way (aka 2 guys) and not being willing to do it your way (aka 2 girls)

  • your girlfriend is a slut simply put, you're in for some shit brah

    • lol notice how guys agree and women disagree, but its cool sluts are gonna hate anyway and since the guys are the ones who are gonna date you then its up to them to decide whats acceptable and whats not so their opinion is the one that matters

  • Doesn't mean she doesn't love you just mean she's a kinky bitch like me lol, let her have it, fulfill her fantasy and I can tell you the love will come your way 10 fold

    • Have you tried?

    • I must be your boy s best friend

    • Yes, in fact I was in the same position, ex boyfriend wanted a threesome with another girl, we did it, or I did it for him.. risky or not we actually did it with my girl friend in school as I knew he found her hot.. so we did it, and afterwards I never felt More loved and appreciated.. not talking about immediately after, but in the months after.. we all did it a few more times, I probably enjoyed it more than him haha.. We broke up but not because of that, he moved far away..

    • Show All
  • Show More (41)