Should men be allowed to vote on abortion laws and issues?

Just asking since the biggest complaint about men weighing in on the issue is 'it's not up to you to decide what a woman can do to her body.' So if a man isn't allowed to tell a woman if she can or can't have an abortion, should they even be allowed to vote on abortion laws?

Also, this is hypothetical.




Yes, men should have a say in what a woman does to her body and the fetus as a citizen of that country
Vote A
No, this is an issue that doesn't concern or directly effect men and they shouldn't be able to tell a woman what to do with her body.
Vote B
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
Girl Guy
Updates:
+1 y
Not even going to lie, I'm surprised anyone even voted for 'no' lol
1 1

Most Helpful Girls

  • Depends on the situation. As far as I'm concerned, if the baby was conceived through a mutual act, then that baby belongs to BOTH people and BOTH people have the right to decide its' fate. When I say "mutual act" -- I'm talking about sex itself. Even if one or both parties used a form of birth control, if they are having willing sex, they are willingly taking on the potential repercussions of their behavior. Don't want to get pregnant? Either don't have sex or get permanently sterilized. Otherwise, you are still 'at risk' for pregnancy, and when you have sex, you take that risk and accept potential responsibility. Yes, I believe that -- if you're willing to have sex without 100% effective method of birth control, you are willing to get pregnant and share that responsibility with the other person. If, as a woman, you don't want that person to have involvement in your future don't have sex with him. I find it terribly ridiculous that women can go to a man who got her pregnant and insist on child support, etc... forcing him to be involved, but then also insist on having the exclusive right ti say what happens to that child before it is born. No... I'm not okay with that. Both people contributed, both people get to decide. Can't agree? Too bad... you accepted this would happen when you chose to engage in sexual activities, you deal with the consequences. Keep in mind that if you can't or don't want that child, there are hundreds and hundreds of couple who desperately want children who cannot have them. As far as I'm concerned, if a couple can't decide what to do, they should be given a time limit to come to a decision, otherwise, any child would then be free to be adopted.

    People say the 'system' is overloaded with kids waiting to be adopted... and that's not entirely true. I am a foster parent, and we want to adopt, but most of those kids we've had are not available for adoption because they have selfish family members who won't "allow" it to happen and prefer that the government foot the bill to raise their kids. Years and years we've dealt with it, so I know. Quite often, these kids aren't wanted at all by their birth parents, but they are stuck in a system because the law favors birth mothers and women. Several of our kids would be in fantastic, loving homes if the men in their lives had more say. (Note, here I'm talking about mutual consent... which are the vast majority of pregnancies.)

    • 100% agree. Some of these women on here are absolutely disgusting.

    • Well said

  • I believe that women should have the right to choose if they want to keep the baby or not in situations like rape etc. If a woman gets pregnant because her and her partner were not careful enough both have the right to decide if they want the baby or not. There are also situations where the family cannot afford a baby and they might think that it's for the best if the woman aborts. I think that men can comment and have opinions but voting not at all because men don't get affected like a woman gets affected during pregnancy and it's a woman who will give birth at the end of the day and there are men who abandon their women ( just like some mums leave their kids behind)

  • Yes.
    True that it is the woman's body but she wouldn't have to deal with pregnancy and/or having an abortion if it weren't for her having sex with the guy. Children aren't delivered by storks. They're conceived via a the fertilization of an egg by sperm. If a guy is required to get a woman pregnant, he should also have the same right as her in respect to what comes of this unborn child.

    • That sperm is an unconditional gift to the girl (unless they DECIDE together to have a baby). Once a manhas given it, it's no longer under his control, like any gift. No say thus.

    • @jacquesvol True if it were a literal gift. I'd say that the similarity between an actual potential future child and a gift wouldn't extend all that far. Unless you're saying that men should also have zero say in the child's future, since he was nothing more than someone there to 'deliver his sperm'?

    • If a child is born and he denies paternity he has no say in education. ( But he still owes child support. ) But as long as no child is born he has no say

    • Show All
  • Yes, they should. The baby was not conceived by only he woman and the baby is NOT her body. I don't give a damn what feminists say. Once your baby starts forming inside of you, it may be INSIDE of your body, but it isn't your body.

    • You do realize that it's just feminists that think that, right?

    • not just*

    • It doesn't matter who thinks that. It isn't their body.

    • Show All

Most Helpful Guys

  • Yes because it impacts them. This idea that its "her body" is narcasistic. The fact is its not her body its their baby ergo he is as much involved in this as she is. She chose this as much as he did whether or not that was intentional is irrelevent. Further more he as a human beign should have a say because as it should go without saying, he was at one point in time a fetus and by extention what a woman does to a fetus his mother could have done to him. Also the fact that many abortion clinics receive money from the government which itself is collected by the populace which does affect men (and since men generally earn more they also pay more in taxes) so it also effects them in this way. But by this reasoning we would actually have to ban women from most voting in general wich I am sure women would be adamantly against. The fact is wars are fought almost entirely by men so that means no woman has the right to weigh in on whether or not a war is justifiable or should be allowed to vote for any one who may or may not put us into a war as it doesn't affect them. They also would not have the right to vote for laws that have any impact on a fathers parental responsibility like child support because its his money not hers. Women would also not really be allowed to weigh in on the draft as by law men have to sign up for it in order to get the right to vote, to drive a car and to take out loans both on state and federal level which women do not have to do so thus the current talks of a female draft would be something they would not be allowed to vote on since men are forced into it automatically etc. etc. etc. Basically its a really crappy argument made by women who don't want to actually confront the argument against abortion (or child support) itself because they can't argue against it. Its a dismissal not an argument, a way to avoid the argument by saying who and who cannot participate i. e. any one who doesn't agree with them shouldn't have a say.

  • "it's not up to you to decide what a woman can do to her body."

    I learned, long ago, that if you let the other person define the issue, they will win the debate, so. . . don't you mean "It shouldn't be up to a man to decide what his sexual partner does to their unborn child, including ending its life?"

    Having restated the issue more clearly, I very strongly disagree!

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls & Guys Said

45 118
  • The ideology does not go limited to "Personal choice" only.
    However, I am a man, i wanna have a voice, and i wanna support women for abortion rights and help them to have this right to choose independently.

    • Me too.

    • thankyou.

    • pass the sick bucket please, the feminist appeasers are out in force.

    • Show All
  • If it's an issue that affects the population, the economy, a man's status as a parent, liability for child support, or even the rights of his daughter or other citizens of the country more generally, then yes.

    Voting is not exclusively limited to male citizens when it comes to:

    1. War
    2. Child support liability
    3. Parental rights
    4. How parenthood is defined
    5. Whether health insurance companies should also pay for the recreational use of medications only men would benefit from (e. g. Cialis, Viagra), just like men have to pay for the purely recreational use of medications only women would benefit from (i. e. Birth control).
    6. Laws affecting persons accused of rape and rape trial generally.

    It's a democracy, not special snowflake land. Everyone has a say on everything. If you don't like it, move to the country you're thinking about... some place more progressive like Canada, or Saudi Arabia.

    Women get to vote on issues that affect men. Stop whining when you realize that it's a two way street.

  • Honesty men shouldn't even be able to comment on this take... I mean they aren't even female, they have no idea how it feels like to have a baby... I'm not judging anyone here BUT you can't judge someone if your not THEM... Yes u may have the same experience and crap but they HAVE THEIR OWN OPINIONS

    • Besides to be real parents you both must be in a real relationship to where BOTH agree with each other... I mean THINK PEOPLE.. If the girl doesn't want the baby but the man does... Well he's obviously not respecting her choice... and it's the same the other way around as well... To conclude why would you even consider abortion if your with the right person? I mean if you really loved each other, the baby would only be there to share the love, not to be separated from each parent cause one wanted it and the other didn't... IF A GIRL didn't HAVE AN ABORTION, the baby wouldn't have LOVE FROM BOTH PARENTS... So the poor kid would have a hard freaking life

  • Maybe when they grow some empathy. But I doubt that will ever happen so nope!
    media.giphy.com/media/UK9VbxLFOAezK/giphy.gif

    • your opinion about men is just because you are surrounded by assholes and you repulse the good guys

    • @samcool092 So what you're saying is the entire country and this website are just like ALL assholes who are against abortion?

    • it depends whether you have already met everyone in the world and then you are against abortion

    • Show All
  • Men have just as much right to their unborn child as women do, so yes.

    • At the moment of legal abortion there's no child. Only a embryo

    • @jacquesvol I don't really care what you call it. It's the beginning of a human being.

    • @laurapalmer Every month all fertile women drop "their beginning of a human being" in their pads and all guys wipe theirs away with a Kleenex several times a week.

    • Show All
  • If he is the father of the child he most certainly has a say in the matter, however they need to respect that if the woman does get an abortion because she feels pressured etc ultimately that can really mess up someone's mental state. But I think the woman needs to really sit down and discuss it with the man too, I feel sorry for men who don't get a say.

  • This is so sad to read. I'm SO HAPPY to live in Canada where women can do whatever the hell they want with their bodies.

    While I agree the woman should tell her partner about her decision, it should be her decision to make in the end. SHE has to carry and deliver the baby and he doesn't. He doesn't even have to stick around and help. He can peace out any time. So unless there's a binding contract for the man to completely be there for the child and mother all the way until its adulthood, he should not be able to stop her from making that decision.

  • It took two to make a baby, so the father should have a say unless he wouldn't participate in the support and raising of the child. Maybe the father wants the child even though the mother doesn't. If a woman is able to make the baby and doesn't make sure one of them is using good protection. A baby doesn't create the accident, two consenting adults do. Pro abortion people claim it's not a human baby until it's born. That's BS that they think supports their side in this. I have one question for those who don't mind killing the baby, if it's truly not a human baby, why does a person who kills a pregnant woman charged with two murders? Seems like the non human baby shouldn't count, right? The lefty abortion supporters can never answer this question because they agree with the double murder charges. Again, the leftest nut jobs don't need any facts to push their phony agenda. Any lie will do.

    • Not only that... those who say such things clearly haven't held, say, a 24 week 'fetus' after being born prematurely. I have. She was fully formed... fingernails and toenails, hair and eyelashes. Perfectly formed, just small. Nobody can tell me she wasn't a human being.

    • @IvyOp AMEN!!

  • You know, Human beings are all created equally. So if it's to the point where abortion is personal there should be some sort of understanding to not have one sided votes. This specifically comes down to what the woman thinks anyway due to her giving birth as it takes much more from a woman than a man when giving birth.

  • men shouldn't vote on abortion laws because the decision really isn't up to them and they aren't the ones with a baby

    • It is their baby too.

    • @Thisperson98 there is no baby and no proof of paternity

  • Yup... women only use "our" ... AFTER the baby is born and she can't handle it. but before all that... its "my... my... my"...
    Talking about unmarried couples...
    If it takes two, i believe two should have a say.

    • Men do have say: Durex or Trojan or a HJ.

    • @jacquesvol short say, these things are liable to break.

    • use spermicide too

    • Show All
  • Well I can see points to both sides but I think ultimately people should be allowed to that cannot directly affect them. Because all laws affect all of us indirectly
    Like here in Ireland, last year or the year before that there was a referendum about marriage equality. Now most people that voted are not gay and I don't see why straight people shouldn't be allowed to vote.

    I think it's too easy to just exclude the people that don't agrree with you. There'll always be reason why someone might to exclude your from voting for something important.
    Remember when some Trump supporters came up with the idea that women should not vote, after polls indicated that if only women voted Hilary would win every state?
    Well by the end of the day I think excluding men from voting for/against abortion isn't all that different

  • Well... There have been some cases where a woman wants to abort her baby yet the dad wants to keep it and raise it. Yet he has no say according to the law in some states and areas. I don't know... I really don't like the idea of killing a baby that had no blame for adults. Even if it was a product of rape... Is hard I know. But a baby is not to blame. Is not the baby's fault to be born without its wishes.

    • At the moment of legal abortion there's no baby. Only an embryo. If the guy wants to impose his religion or ideas on a girl, he should look for one willing to accept that.

    • @jacquesvol I know. I'm just saying both have a say. Since both are the future parents of that baby. And I know. I don't like abortion but I know that there are some cases and they are free to do what they want. As long as they abort when is on the embryo stage.

    • @lovydoey He has the right to try to convince her. Not to force her. Forcing a girl to carry out an unwanted pregnancy and to go through labor and childbirth is worse than rape.

    • Show All
  • I think it depends part of me feels like it's the women's body and life but at same time it's also another living thing involved so I could see how if the guy wanted keep the baby but the woman wanted abortion I see it from that view. I do feel like the guy should respect the woman's decision on it and if has issue they should talk see from each other's points.

  • Even if a woman has the "right" to abort, that brings up moral and behavioral issues that pertain to the society as a whole. Of course, the same is true if they decide to have the child and give it to adoption.
    Another issue that needs to be considered is whether they should be given priority when going to the hospital or be covered by health insurance. Obviously others shouldn't have to pay taxes for that, in my opinion.
    As a side note, if every doctor refuses to perform such abortion, then there isn't even a right to demand.

    Therefore, yes, we are all entitled to vote on that matter and an individual's behaviour affects everyone.

  • I honestly hate your poll options. You are obviously very biased on this situation.

    • Oh, it's very clear.

  • I think so. Especially if it is a situation where his child is on the verge of living or dying.

  • My body... my rules...

  • No, men should have no say.
    And seeing as Roe V Wade was decided by supreme court that was all male, it should be thrown out, rendering all abortion illegal, until we have an all female supreme court available to revisit the case.
    After all, who did those men think they were, making a decision on that?

    • I know you're joking, but it's generally a good think to allow freedom to others and a bad thing to restrict something without a very good reason.

    • @goaded well, abortion kind of limits the freedom to that human being by killing it, so...

    • your comment assumes that the default is illegal abortion. the default in nature is actually legal abortion.

  • Option A seems a little bias to me. I don't think it has anything to do with wanting to give input on a woman's body, it should focus more on the child. It takes two people to make a child, in the cases of a father wanting to keep the child but the mother wants to abort it; his opinion is definitely valid.

  • Show More (143)