Ladies, Johnny Depp or Brad Pitt?

Okay, no gay jokes please. But yesterday I had a debate with my girl (not really my girl...its complicated actually...she still uses my Mach 3 though, which is a huge thing for me and caused me to ask a question about it on here, but anyways) and we had an argument on whose hotter. Johnny Depp or Brad Pitt? Okay, I'm not gay or bisexual or anything, but if you ask me, I'd say Johnny Depp. She kept telling me that Brad Pitt is hotter, I said why and she said he has nice muscles. So then I told her that I don't have any muscles, what about me? and she said...Brad Pitt is hotter...then our friends in the background said we are LAME for having these dumb ass debates...but anyways, I was wondering, what women think, Johnny Depp or Brad Pitt?
Johnny Depp
Vote A
Brad Pitt
Vote B
I don't think either of them is attractive
Vote C
I find both equally attractive
Vote D
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
Girl Guy
Updates:
+1 y
Okay people, Johnny Depp or Brad Pitt are the options, you can't fill out Choice F on a scan tron sheet on your exam if Choice F is not even an option.
+1 y
OMG PEOPLE, STOP TALKING ABOUT CAPTAIN SPARROW, JOHNNY DEPP WAS SO MUCH HOTTER IN DON JUAN DEMARCO, HAS EVERYONE FORGOTTEN THAT MOVIE?
+1 y
I just realized how gay that update sounded. This whole question is NO HOMO. FYI
+1 y
Brad Pitt is the next Robert Redford. Johnny Depp is so ahead of his time he IS the next Johnny Depp.
0 0

Most Helpful Girls

  • johnnnayyyyyy

    1. he is smart

    2. he is funny

    3. he is awesome

    4. he is johnny depp

    5. he makes an awesome pirate

    6. he makes an even more awesome psycho barber-killer dude

    7. he makes an even, even more awesome psycho writer-killer dude

    8. he is JOHNNNNAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

    :D

    • what about awesome bank robber dude

  • johnny depp. I love his olive skin, dark eyes. not much of a body though but he is so sexy in pirates of the caribbean when he has that deep tan and dreads

    brad looked good in fight club and he's cute when he has some facial hair, but not the scruffy mountain man look. other than that he's a little too pretty boy for me

  • Johnny Depp cos he's a brilliant actor and ply some versatile roles! The mad hatter can't be beatened!

Most Helpful Guy

  • As a guy, gotta say both are pretty attractive from what I can tell is considered male attractive. No homo, obviously :P

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls & Guys Said

14 4
  • Johnny Depp is sexy. He has features on the softer side, but Brad Pitt was unbearably sexy in the movie, "Mr. and Mrs. Smith", so as long as he looks exactly like that, then it's a toss up for me. Haha. Thanks.

    Jamaica Outtttttttt

  • Johnny Depp without a doubt!

    As Brad Pitt gets older, he loses his sexy appeal to me for some reason, but Johnny is just sexy all the time.

    • Brad Pitt is the next Robert Redford. Johnny Depp is so ahead of his time he IS the next Johnny Depp.

  • I chose Johnny Depp. His features are much more exotic and sensual (in my opinion). I don't think there's anything special about Brad Pitt.

  • Neither ! Let's go with Shemar Moore...so sexy ! (;

    • I would select your answer as the best answer but for some reason every time I try to place my mouse pointer on the best answer check box something crazy happens...like I get logged out of GAG, or my computer freezes or a pop up screen pops up telling me JAVA ERROR: CAN'T SELECT AS BEST ANSWER

    • go ahead mama! Shemar Moore is beautiful! Now a list is starting...haha. Jamaica Outtttttt

    • Awww ): @chondell ha ha yep ! n& gotta rep the JA !

  • Johnny Depp
    I was first captivated by him in one of his earlier movies, "Benny and Joon". It was a scene where he was sleeping on a couch or something. My actual thoughts were "Wow, he's really good-looking. He's beautiful".

  • I like Brad more than the bad-boy Johnny look but that's probably just me.

  • Johnny! with out thinking twice...

    he's edgy and a bit crazy...brad is just normal..nothing special about his look :S

    Johnny*&^%$

  • Johnny Depp...no contest...more specifically, the Captain Jack Sparrow version of Depp.

    • Captain Sparrow is nothing compared to when Johnny Depp was in Don Juan Demarco!

    • I'll give you that one. :) But still, there's just something about a pirate. He's also incredible in The Tourist.

  • I don't like any of them.

  • i am better looking than both

  • johnny is fine asl 😭

  • I distinguish between pretty and beautiful. Pretty is daily and Beauty is seldom and unique. In my opinion is Johnny Depp pretty. But Brad Pitt is a Beauty (😮) and belongs to the Most Beautiful Male Faces I have ever seen.

  • Depp is so much hotter in my book

  • Funny how she said she loved Brads muscles but you don't have any. You better get some son. Just know that your woman is more attracted to guys out there that are more manly than you. Plus if she likes muscles she probably loves a nice thick **** to fill her up. So hope you're good in that respect too but I suspect not considering that she made the comments about Brad.

    • actually while having sex one day, while riding me like a horse, she screamed out "I want to have your babies!" so I think I'm fine, but thanks for the concern and thanks for your attempt to get a reaction out of me which actually failed.

    • well at least you know the truth.

    • Sorry to break it to you friend, but just because a guy has nice muscles doesn't mean that all girls will necessarily hook up with him, it has more to do with personality and chemistry, if you were smart you would know that. But you're not, which is why you posted a dumb ass comment like this.

    • Show All
  • Who do the ladies think could put it down better in the bed. That is the question. Depps style vs Pitt's substance.

    • not exactly trying to picture either of those actors in bed with any woman, especially not my girl

    • Your girl would likely want to date Depp and get f***ed by Pitt.

    • One things for sure, she'd never f*** you with your horrible sense of humor.

  • brad pitt is one good looking dude (no homo)

    • ironically, more guys seem to think so then women, women think he is bland in the aggregate and yet so many guys think he's a sex symbol, ironic.

  • Brad Pitt is attractive, but in an average, almost boring way. I've never understood why people go nuts over him. Johnny Depp is exotic, sensual, multifaceted and unpredictable, with an amazing talent. Much more swoon worthy in my opinion.

    • Well, I think Brad Pitt is a very charming guy, I think he has great control over his facial expressions, being able to use his smile when words fail him, check out an interview with oprah winfrey and brad pitt. however, I think his acting is very similar throughout a lot of his roles, while JD can act in roles completely different from other roles, plus JD can pull of eyeliner unlike many guys .

    • Nothing wrong with Brad Pitt, I just think he's kind of a typical movie star. Johnny Depp stands out to me more and seems more creative, artistic, and unusual. He has played so many fasninating and completely different roles. I just don't think Brad is any competition for his artistic abilities.

  • Johnny Depp is attractive in an exotic, sensitive way. Brad Pitt is attractive in a good-looking boy next door way. I chose Brad Pitt.

    • I'm an exotic sensitive boy next door. I AM HOTTER THAN BOTH