Supersize vs Superskinny! (guys, if you had to choose one..)

Lately I have been watching the show supersize vs superskinny, its amazing how the UK has no problem with nudity lol, anyways.. Guys If you had to choose between a girl that was close to being anorexic, or close to being obese, and both had great personalities and pretty faces, who would you choose and why?
0 0

Most Helpful Guys

  • I was going to say supersize... but then I thought of the reasons behind why each is specifically one or the other. I imagine the supersize girl is that big simply because she lacks will power and self discipline, whereas the superskinny one just has self image problems that most will mature from so I doubt its a long term thing. So based on that I would choose the superskinny one.

    I thought Canada wasn't as prudish as the US with nudity? I know I've seen during American reality shows that go as far as pixialating girls butts if they are fully clothes yet their pants are riding up their butt enough to form a crease :P. I mean its strange to me... what's the big deal, its not p*rn? lol

  • both cus they both have nice faces and personalities, one can gain weight, the other can lose weight, but its errelevent to my needs. and if he's a cheater he will go for chubby one and cheat with a skinny or the oppossite, like I said to me its the face and smile plus personality and I agree with the one guy that says, the skinny one may have issues, most skinny but hot girls I been with all had a bit of personality issues and even a bit of bipolar ! hahah

Most Helpful Girl

  • Ew both of these choices are bad but if I HADDD too it would be the obese guy as long as he had a really cute face, nice swag and he has to be very tall to even out some of that fat distribution. he would have to be close to perfect in every other way if he's gonna be obese.

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls & Guys Said

0 9
  • neither. plus I would have to see her face I care more about a girls face than body

  • If I had to choose, it would have to be the larger woman. Skinny girls turn me off more than fat girls and I prefer meat on the bones.

  • I would choose the nearly obese girl because I think the other one would likely come with a lot of mental issues that would make her less suitable as a candidate for a relationship.

  • I'd say it's amazing how muc a problem the US has with nudity. Because seeing a pair of boobs will influence teenagers in a bad way *facepalm*

    • lol sssh, but we have shows like 16 and pregnant :P anyways I don't have a problem with UK shows.

    • I wasn't saying you though.

  • You'd be surprised at how normal "close to being obese" can look. link

    So I'd choose "supersize."

    And to people saying "well she can lose/gain weight," if that's her natural body weight, it's not metabolically healthy to force herself out of it.

    • hmm those pic are interesting, a lot of them that say overweight look average, healthy size to me :/ if that's the case I'm overweight lol.

    • Yeah, it's all according to BMI, so it just goes to show how flawed it is. Someone can be overweight just because they have more *muscle* than average, or a stronger frame.

  • So long as super skinny does not mean anorexic, I prefer it over super size.

    I prefer small boobs even to the point of nipples on pecs versus jumbos and skinny is more compatible with giving oral sex, which I enjoy.

  • I live in the Uk but I don't really watch that

    i thought America was worse until I saw a clip of a UK sex ed show on a p*rn site

    and people were amazed it could be shown on tv

    but for your question, It's hard because the skinny person has to put on a bit of weight and get rid of her eating disorder

    the obese girl needs to lose a lot of weight and have better eating/exercising habits

    it's pretty similar but I pick anorexic

  • Superskinny for sure...(:

  • Neither.