Thick penis, boring conversation. Thin penis, decent conversation. Who do you date?

Preface: I've decided to run through all the categories and ask all the questions I'm allowed to, for a week each. I'm bored. So what if I chose Sexuality first? Ladies, pretend you are dating two guys. One has a nice thick penis. You have to carry the conversation most of the time, and he never really enthralls you with his witty reparte. The other is a gas to hang out with and talk, but in bed it feels like he had a carrot between his legs. We'll even out the personalities a little, pretend there's something else that's attractive about thick-e-thick, like he is a professional masseuse/hair stylist/car mechanic, or whatever else might even the score. Maybe Slim Jim farts in bed or something. Apologies for coarseness, of course. Anywho, one finds out about the other, they're exhibiting signs of a knuckledragging fist fight about to occur, oh my! Eventually they both tell you that you must choose one over the other. Neither really wants a commitment, and neither do you, but they just hate one another, and can't be attracted to you if they know you also see their arch nemesis. When you study all the variables and compare them, you're magically down to one defining characteristic: girth being the most noticeable difference between the two men. What do you do, what do you say? Best answer gets carrot cake. Or something.
Updates:
+1 y
Note: the goal was to make both men eaually attractive, in a relationship sense. Perhaps the thicker guy does everything he can to communicate how he feels without speaking, but offers the hope that you can draw him out of his shell. If you're a big conversationalist, the thinner man has to have some drawbacks to make him equal as a boyfriend with the thick man. Deciding between two men, one with conversation skills but a thin penis, the other with potential and a thick one, which do you choose...
+1 y
*equally
0 0

Most Helpful Girls

  • this isn't really realistic as I probably wouldn't be dating someone whose personality is like you described or someone with a thin penis, and if its about them more than me, then I would easily just drop them both. and how is the only noticeable difference their penis size, if their personalities are completely different ? but okay...

    I'd pick the guy with the thick cock, obviously. if you're not even that into me, then I'm probably not that into you, or at least I know I shouldn't be, and there doesn't seem to be anything gained or lost here in your description.

    thin cocks are not ideal but there are sex toys that help add thickness and sometimes different textures and stuff. so, while I would want a thicker penis, if I was really crazy about him, we had a serious connection, and I could see myself being in a relationship with him long term, and he knew how to give great foreplay, great oral sex, liked to try different things, and stuff and wasn't embarrassed or too proud to wear penis enhancing sex toys then sure, we could make that work.

    • Yep. It was difficult writing this and making it more holistic in scope. The simple underlying question is whether a woman would stick with the thicker or the thinner guy, if she felt the same level of "relationship attraction" for both. That's why I tried to skew the description of the thicker guy towards someone that is more intuitively attractive in nonverbal ways. Communicates without speaking as well as the thin man who offers better verbal communication skills. Guess it needs a rewrite?

  • Who would you rather spend 7 hours in a hospital waiting room with, waiting for a non-emergency but still upsetting situation to finish that should have been finished in the first hour if the orderlies were't incompetent?

    The only magazine is a three year old copy of Today's Parent.

    • The thick guy has a heart of gold and Mr Conversation can be a little cynical.

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls & Guys Said

2 0
  • Who has nicer eyes?

    • Alan Thicke

    • he's old.

    • I'm old. And I've been told I have nice eyes. Mr Thick, with the nice kind eyes. Or liquid blue eyes. Or flaming red eyes. Whichever you prefer, I'm giving them to thick dude.

    • Show All
  • Who makes more money?

    • Thick guy makes a good living but owns his business, and sometimes that means going into overtime. Thin guy makes the same money, but has twelve degrees and works part time, surrounded constantly by his witty friends, even when not at work.

    • I couldn't be satisfied with carrots all my life, so I would choose thick guy.