I had this happen for the first time ever with my current boyfriend, lol. I froze up in pain and just tried to breathe through it, because my reaction let him know what had happened immediately, and he ceased all contact to make sure I was okay. He felt so bad about it. I know it was accidental, because as a girl who enjoys anal, it's not like he has to twist my arm about it or talk me into it when he wants to switch to anal, and we often switch at MY request. The situation was like this: We were in the back of my car with one of the doors open. I was in doggy and he was standing just outside the open door. It was dark out, things were extremely well-lubricated, and we were going at it pretty damn rough, at high speeds, lol. On one stroke, he pulled back too far and slipped out, and went to shove himself back inside. Which normally goes fine and is awesome. But THIS time his aim was off, and the full force [not breaking rhythm, just as hard and fast] of it slammed into the wroooong place. It was with enough force that he was almost fully inside in a split second, one long stroke, not just the tip. It was EXTREMELY painful.
Like I said, I like anal. Even rough anal, after a bit of preparation. If I'd been in any way prepared for what happened, even just being aware that it was coming, my pain would have been greatly reduced.
So yes, it definitely can happen, though that was the first and only time I'd experienced more than just a rough nudge knocking at the wrong door, lmao.
I was in a year and a half relationship and it never happened. Then I had a year break from dating at which the end of had a three night stand sort of thing with this sleazy guy, and he did this! He said it was an accident, but I think he was lying. I am going on a year with my current boyfriend and it has not happened. The time this did happen though, with the sleazy guy it was crippling! I curled up in a ball from the pain. I have anal with my boyfriend now which took a little convincing considering previous experience and it isn't painful if you go very slow, which is really surprising because It feels like a knife if you are not careful. If it is truly an accident that some guys make, please be considerate and careful. Think of this as the worst possible mistake you can make. Also, if you are into trying anal some day, your likelihood of that happening becomes low pretty fast. I don't know if I would want to attempt anal with someone that sloppy anyway given it is a very delicate process that requires patience and empathy.
I think it's safe to assume it wasn't an accident with that guy. Well done for not letting it put you off for good.
Had it happen just awhile ago. It was definitely an accident and I think gave him an answer on if we'd have anal anytime soon: no! We are both each other's firsts and so he was goin pretty fast n it slipped out so he tried to recover fast and well, failed. I was in pain n couldn't sit up for a few mins. He had no clue what happened until I explained when the pain went down. He felt pretty bad. Once I was good I decided to take control the rest of the night lol
Yup. Just once. It was in the missionary position, and a lot of her juices had ran down her butt. I pulled back a little too far and the next thrust went down her ass crack and up her ass. Not far - maybe just two inches or so, but the surprising thing is that she didn't yelp in pain or anything. She did have kind of a 'shocked' face for a few moments, though.
We didn't discuss it or anything... She knew I liked anal and she loathed it. If we talked about it, she probably knew the conversation would eventually turn to me asking for anal again.
Yes, I've done it a couple of times. It happens when things get wild and wet. Ouch!
I've also done the reverse...slipped into her vagina when doing her ass. That REALLY pisses her off because of potential infection.
Actually yes, when I think about it the reverse has happened before.
Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions
What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!Depending on the position and rhythm, it's been poked hard against my ass on several occasions, but never actually penetrated in one thrust. An unexpected hard thrust against it can be quite painful though.
It's happened to me, things were a little too wet and it was in the dark. It really hurt, with blood and everything :(
Oh, that's awful. Poor you :(
That has happened to me twice. It was pretty shocking lol! It has only happened when we were doing doggy.
Yes, the three people who mentioned it to me were all doing doggy at the time. So how deep did it go in, do you think. Just the tip or deeper than that?
Deeper than that. But I like anal so it was fine, just shocking.
ah OK. Must have hurt a bit still, tho?
Yeah, usually when the female is on top.. The woman are relaxed and going all out riding their man and it slips out and they kinda sit on it.. It's usually just the one thrust and only the tip because it's a shock like no other to the unexpecting!!
That would never and has never happened with me and I get very wet.
This is what I'd originally thought. Even when a girl has been quite literally dripping all over me, I just couldn't see how I could accidentally slip into such a tight space.
Precisely. First of all you couldn't just "slip" in there physically, it would require some work (no matter how wet the surrounding area may be. Secondly you couldn't just "slip" in there without my permission. Just because we're having sex doesn't mean we can have anal sex.
Once or twice, yes. That has happened. Like onlyaguy said, it can when sh*t's all wild and stuff, people get carried away. I will tell you this: it will startle the bejeezus out of you... if you are on the recieving end. One second everything is awesome and it feels good, and the next there is a thing where a thing wasn't before and we didn't even work up to it and I wasn't ready and HOLY GOD, that's painful!
I can imagine it would be incredibly painful. So how deep inside are we talking?
Sexual Relationships 
Sexual Health 
Most Helpful Girls