11-19 in the first link. Though I'm not a huuuuge fan of 11-12, it's basically on the verge of being too muscly for me, but still kind of acceptable I guess.
In the second link, I think builtfat and ottermode look the best. Bearmode is OK too. I'm not all that into muscles really. I like it when guys look naturally healthy and as if they only visit the gym every once in a while. I'm not a fan of huge muscles because it gives off the impression that the guy is obsessed with going to the gym and all that crap, which I'm not all that into.
Every girl is different and at the end of the day personality can trump weight - I once had a crush on a guy who was 270 easy. That said, my ideal is probably in the 13-19% range (skinnyfat to builtfat) Over 30% I start to lose interest. A lot of times it's connected to fitness too - if you're bigger but play sports, go hiking, etc. and are in fairly good shape, it's not as big a deal as it is if you have trouble participating. But that might just be me since I'm fairly active.
Going purely based on looks...
On the Athlean-X chart, I find 8%-19% attractive. The two guys in the beginning are way too big, particularly the first guy. I'm not attracted to any of the types from 20-40%. My favorite would be between 11-15%.
On the Male Bodytype Chart, I'm attracted to Ottermode, Athletic, Skinnyfat, and Builtfat. Not attracted to the others. My favorite would be a mix between Ottermode and Athletic.
First link, I have to say the first four guys are near impossible to look like. They may be on steroids. I don't think it's a good idea to look at those charts.
I think it's best to try to eat right and exercise to the best of your abilities.
If a woman only wants you for pure looks only, she isn't worth your time.
Wow that second link is everything wrong with society. The same mentality that makes pretty girls think they are fat. That "builtfat" one. Who the F would call that fat? The first link is science and way better.
Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions
What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!25-30 is perfect for me.
In the first link, 11%-24%
In the second link, I find Ottermode, Athletic and builtfat most attractive. I actually really like the look of the builtfat look but not a lot of guys have that. I assume it takes a certain body type to have it.
As a clearcut Builtfat man, thank you :)
11-24% in the first link and skinny fat, ottermode, and builtfat for the second link.
Like someone else mentioned, personality def trumps the looks if you are looking for a long-term relationship.
For me anything between 10% and 20% is near damn perfect, up to 30% it's good enough. Above that... well, I don't really get to pick and choose, but that's not exactly how I imagine a Prince Charming.
Well...Id say mine is pretty good.
I think 8-15% on the first chart, and Ottermode, Athletic, and Builtfat on the second. I asked my wife, who's an 8/10 hottie, what she likes (honestly) and she said Ottermode or Athletic ONLY. Damn, I gotta get to work!
11-19% = good
Ottermode - Athletic = good
Sexual Relationships 
Sexual Health 
Most Helpful Girls