Are Jansport backpacks really that good?

Ingrid422
Or are they only in trend?

I'm thinking of guetting one. Roots backpacks always fall apart after one year. My swiss gear backpack held up for 2-3 years but now the shoulder straps are falling apart - plus I find it pretty bulky for my taste. I think Jansport backpacks are a better size but I'm wondering:

- Are they durable? (lots of heavy science bibles to carry around)

- Are they comfortable? (shoulder straps and back cushioning - I hate when the fabric is so thin that all the books dig into my back)

- Do they hold up a lot of stuff? It looks a little small to me.

- What about laptop carrying?

I'm also considering purchasing this:

link

It claims to be indestructible but it might be too small or uncomfortable when very filled.
Updates
+1 y
Updates
+1 y
Sorry link doesn't work. I was referring to a Cocotte messenger bag in size Alfredo or Fred
Are Jansport backpacks really that good?
9 Opinion