Most Helpful Girl
I say give it some more time. You were together for 5 years, you broke up with her, I think you can give her a few months to sort out her feelings.
Most Helpful Guy
I think you should walk away.
I have seen numerous couples split up, get back together only to split up again down the line. You could spend years splitting up and getting back together before finally admitting that things are dead.
Everything in this life is finite, it has a start (the friendship), a middle (the relationship) and an end (the break up).
This relationship has come to its end.