Most Helpful Girl
Most Helpful Guy
Initially, yes. It usually results in a sweet moment where you both step back and realize that you despite what happened, even though things can't be like before, you still care about each other.
The problem is, if you're anything like me, the little spark from that sweet moment will fester and undo much of the progress you'd made in trying to get over her. Then next thing you know, you're day-dreaming about trying to get her back again even though you know its fruitless.
All in all, I'd say its a neutral exchange. You gain a moment of sweetness in exchange for a headache/heartache down the road.