Most Helpful Guy
You have no obligation to return anything that was given to you as a gift, and that includes dinners and entertainment. If you had a physical relationship, ask him (not seriously, of course) if he should compensate you for all of the physical pleasure you gave him. The real problem is that he is extremely angry and 1) this is his way of showing you how angry it is, and 2) this is his way of prolonging the breakup, because in his mind, it's not over yet.
Do return the family heirloom but have him sign a receipt for it. Tell him that you have no obligation to pay him for anything else and that, if he continues to contact you about this, you will get an injunction against him for stalking or harassment. Block him on your phone and on social media. But be sure to follow through on anything that you threaten.
Most Helpful Girl
Relax, @Emmajay, and Consider Him history and along with This...350$ to cover all costs he took me too, he wants me to return all gifts he gave me...
He cannot Get a rock out of a penny, this Penny Pincher and with being a sore sport, he is a sore loser as well.
Move on and chalk it up as his big loss in a relationship that he could not even take to the bank to make you happy in.
As far as the Dunkin Donut hole toy cops go, they will Merely laugh in his face, as he stands there with egg all over it, as they scoff down their grub and tell him to take it up in Small Claims Court.
He is a bozo, jumping through hoops here, dear. He has not a receipt to show nor a window to throw out his Hissing and Moaning out of.
Yes, I will agree, being it Might be an Heirloom, mail back granny her locket and close this chapter to a book that was not worth its weight in God... Just got old.
Good luck and Good riddance to him. xx