Most Helpful Girl
Break up with girlfriend. It just isn't working, and I'm pretty sure girlfriend knows about hometown girl.. which could have been the catalyst. And to continue with a broken relationship is a waste of time. Why girlfriend hasn't cut it off with you, I don't know. As for hometown girl... just because you click while you are in a relationship, doesn't mean you will click when you are single. So after you break up with girlfriend, don't jump into another relationship with homegirl. Just keep talking and hanging out. If the sparks are still there after 3 months of both being single, then you know you have something strong to build on.