I am trying to figgure out what went wrong. I still think the convo went pretty well although I can get shy too and there were some minor moments of silence. The other thing I can only think of is that I got a phonecall from my boss in the middle of the film + she saw a message from my friend on Facebook asking me if I want to go out tonight. She seemed different after the movie.
I really like this girl and I am pretty sure she felt the same (she even said this to me in a way). I don't know what could have went wrong. Fyi we watched the new horror movie "Rings" (she likes horror movies) lol. This girl (even by others!) is known to be VERY shy and introverted.