Most Helpful Guy
Probably unless she was a model or something and her profession required her to be appealing to the widest range of people. In that case I'd assume she would be proactive and do something if the answers weren't to her liking.
If she doesn't fit this criteria, I'd find it at least mildly annoying that a girlfriend of mine needs this kind of validation.1
Most Helpful Girl
I wouldn't care if my boyfriend did that. If he started flirting with any of them though, that would definitely bother me.0