Cheerful, peppy girls or quiet, mysterious girls?

Anonymous
In general, which do you prefer:
- A really chatty, effusive girl who's always smiling, wears her heart on her sleeve and is more "flirty"
OR
- A more reserved, mysterious girl who rarely lets on what she's feeling, but is interesting and will open up under the right circumstances?
A lot of guys I meet say they actually like girls who are more quiet, but they always seem to go for the loud, outgoing ones. Why do they say one thing and then do another?
Peppy, smiley girl
Vote A
Reserved, mysterious girl
Vote B
Results please
Vote C
Select age and gender to cast your vote:
GirlGuy
Cheerful, peppy girls or quiet, mysterious girls?
27
5
Add Opinion