Nice logic! Lmao :)
By your logic, I would go for B. Most chubby chicks can lose some weight and look fine. Get a fat chick to lose weight and you'll have a lot of lose skin, stretch marks, and some funky looking boobs. Chubby chicks may have some stretch marks, but wouldn't be much worse than a pregnant woman.
Nice Vegeta face
Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions
Fat is something temporary , beauty however is not