I personally liked RBY the best for the original pokemon, towns, etc. But I recently listened through the RBY and GSC soundtrack, and I have to say some GSC tracks were beautiful, even the surfing theme. During development, it was thought to be the last Pokemon game, and the production quality and diversity reflected that. RSE was a huge visual upgrade with new features that made the game more immersive without being annoying or cluttered, and it was the most fun in my opinion.
Sorry for not including the newer games. I haven't played them and I wanted a more focused debate between these three.
- Red, Blue, Yellow (Green?)Vote A
- Gold, Silver, CrystalVote B
- Ruby, Saphire, EmeraldVote C
Most Helpful Guy
Gen 2 and 4.0