Do you think a person who lies about their fighting/martial arts/athletic background should be just as socially scorned as a person who?

lies about their military background/status?

For instance, let's say you found a person who claims to be a black belt at a martial art or a golden gloves amateur boxing champion, only to later figure out that he/she is a phony just by how very little knowledge he/she has about his/her martial art that he/she trains in or a sport that he/she trained for. How would you feel about that?

As someone who is not only currently an amateur boxer but also has a father that both served in the US Army and was a professional boxer (with his amateur boxing background since his childhood up to his military service years) for a short while after he was honorably discharged, I'd be just as highly pissed of a phony golden gloves boxing champ or fake black belt (of any martial art) as I would with a phony military veteran with fake medal of honors. That's a huge slap in the face to those who've worked very hard for those achievements.

I can sense a fake amateur/pro boxer and a fake military service member when I see one (by asking what rolling and slipping a punch is or what a smoker is in boxing and asking them where were they in for their MOS, their military ID or what an MOS even is for military/US Army) after gaining my amateur boxing experience and learning a lot about the military from my father.

After watching these youtube videos, it just made my blood boil.

[Fake Black Belt]

[In case you don't know who Charlie Zelenoff (bald white guy in a black tank top shirt) is, he's a troll well-known among the internet boxing sensation for his fake amateur boxing stories and became a pro through his BS and yes, almost any person can become a professional boxer without even amateur background by passing a physical test and registering for a pro boxing state license. However, it takes a real talented amateur boxer to capture any attention from a decent promoter, manager, cornerman, and organization to get anywhere near close to the top.]

[Fake Army Ranger]

  • Yes
    Vote A
  • No
    Vote B
  • Depends
    Vote C
  • Other Perspective
    Vote D
Select age and gender to cast your vote:
I'm a GirlI'm a Guy


Most Helpful Girl

  • Yes to the military one, because these are people who have gone through EXTREME struggle, both physically and mentally and have served the country in a way that a fighter has not. Now, I have MMA experience, so it annoys me, yes, but it's no where on the level of disrespect I feel when someone tries to impersonate a veteran. Because the thing is, if you claim to know how to fight and someone dusts your ass, that's no skin off my back, you just look dumb.

    • Show All
    • hi, could you message me? I'd like some advice from you

Recommended Questions

Have an opinion?

What Girls & Guys Said

  • i couldn't care less unless I am calling them my master/trainer.

    I only train to protect myself and others, although people are telling me I should enter amateur fights. but right now it's not in my strongest interest (off topic)

    but yeah, if they are exposed, whatever. I'll just find another one. I get a good feel of them to see if they're legit. I'm confident with my current trainer, he knows his shit.

  • A black belt's contribution to society pales in comparison to a war veteran, so no, I do not think they deserve punishment. Or at least not the same punishment as someone who has committed false valour.

  • The Solder or so called Solder, For all that Solders and
    /Brothers in Arms we did loose I would knock that guy out an strip him of every patch he had


The only opinion from girls was selected the Most Helpful Opinion, but you can still contribute by sharing an opinion!

Recommended myTakes