Most Helpful Guy
Scarlett's sass and fire is sexy, but she was a bit too high pedestal after a time. Melanie was always solid throughout.
Most Helpful Girl
To be honest, I don't really admire either one of them so I feel like I can't pick. Lol They both have pros and cons.
While I do like that Scarlett wasn't afraid to voice her true opinions, she was also kind of a bitch who used her looks to get her way 90% of the time and didn't care who got hurt in the process. Melanie was sweet at least but to the point of being a doormat.
I guess for the sake of this question, if I HAD to pick one, it would be Melanie (although I only like her slightly more than Scarlett because both of them annoyed me. haha!)