Most Helpful Guy
I don't like make up on a girl. It makes me feel like she's trying too hard, and borderline desperate, unless its a special occasion.
I don't mind a girl dressing casual. We're all human after all! We let our genders define us too much!
Most Helpful Girl
Effort in appearance is appreciated for both genders. I guess with the options you have given, that would depend on the situation like where you are going or what you would be doing.