Small butt vs. big butt, which one do you prefer?

whyisitso Editor

This is a very superficial question, but I've noticed these ones get the most attention. Let's see what you think about this one!

The trend has been saying big butts are better, but is that really true?

Small butt

Vote A

Big butt

Vote B

Other

Vote C

Select gender and age to cast your vote:

Girl Guy

0 1

Most Helpful Guys

Anonymous
+1 y
I like all kinds, but if you want an honest answer then big butts.
If I'm walking behind a woman with a fat ass I can't help but look at it.
I love them. : )
1 0 0 0
AbdKilani Guru
+1 y
But a butt is good as a butt should but if it is not a butt I wouldn't bother
So.
Smaller or big as long as it is a butt it is okay
1 0 0 0
- AbdKilani
  +1 y
  Thanks for the Mho dear

Most Helpful Girl

DocilexElle Yoda
+1 y
I like a man with a nice muscular ass and a woman with a tight butt (big or small)!
1 0 0 0
- DocilexElle
  +1 y
  Thanks lol

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls & Guys Said

4 28

SarahVanRensburg Yoda
+1 y
Small just looks better...
1 1 0 0
TheUniqueOne96 Master
+1 y
Big for me.
2 1 2 0
- TheUniqueOne96
  +1 y
  A simple preference opinion and yet two down votes? Lol, wow.
ThisDudeHere Master
+1 y
It honestly doesn't matter if her face is good. I've liked girls with very small butts before and I've liked ones with bigger ones - it's the face that draws me in.
1 0 0 0
ecfresh Master
+1 y
Smaller is healthier and I prefer healthy.
2 0 1 0
- Dashee
  +1 y
  Pear shaped girls have been proven to be healthier and to live longer. Your shallow statement is hella invalid.
- ecfresh
  +1 y
  Shallow? I was asked which I prefer and gave an honest answer. Too often do I see 'big butts' being classified as sexy these days and for me I prefer a smaller butt. That's not a shallow answer, because if she is healthy you don't know how 'small' I mean when I say it. I consider many models who are super skinny unhealthy and therefore not attractive.
- Dashee
  +1 y
  What I meant with shallow was you assuming small butts to be healthy and big butts to be unhealthy. I'm not talking overweight girls, cause usually they don't JUST have big butts. Small butts usually have 0 shape in tight jeans, while big butts do. I don't know what you thought of when you read "small vs big" but it didn't say average vs overweight, or normal vs huge.
- Show All Show Less
- ecfresh
  +1 y
  Got ya. Yes if small means flat that’s not attractive. I see images of bigger butts and the women have large thighs and are overweight. Compared to someone with shapely legs and a smaller butt. No worries, I really don’t care much about the butt anyway, breasts are much more eye catching to me honestly
wankiam Master
+1 y
i much prefer the first girls shape and also her panties too
1 0 0 0
BeMuse Master
+1 y
Why's it always a comparison between pasty pancake butt and thunder thighs overweight Wal-Mart shopper donkeys on this site. It's like no one has ever seen a Spanish girl before...

0 0 3 2
- whyisitso
  +1 y
  That's not very different from either of those buttstock, just different angles and position. And why is it called a Spanish butt? That kind of butt is quite common everywhere.
- BeMuse
  +1 y
  It's way different. The first girl you posted has no ass but is popping her back and pushing her toes up. The second girl ou posted has thighs that are thicker than her back. They are opposite extremes.
- whyisitso
  +1 y
  Exact same thing happening on your first pic. And in the second picture she might have as thick thighs, you don't know because she is lying down. But well, this question has to have pictures that are different from each other. And some here has been saying the butt in the first pic isn't even small. Compared to her body size it is quite big and won't dissappear even if she wasn't standing like that.
- Show All Show Less
- BeMuse
  +1 y
  I know the first pic I posted is arching her back that's why I posted the second pic... Its the same woman (back/side views)... Anyway if you have ever drawn people you'd be able to understand the perspective. That first girl posted has no ass. There are plenty of small tight butt bikini models that actually have a round butt just more petite than the girl I posted.
- whyisitso
  +1 y
  Well, she does even if you don't think she has one.
- BeMuse
  +1 y
  Follow the angle of her arched back. You see how it follows the same line all the way out to the bottom of her underwear line and then drops off. That's the real shape of her butt. It's flat all the way to the underwear line with a little muscle/fat hanging at the bottom.
- whyisitso
  +1 y
  You think you know something about anatomy? Well, I happen to know, and you really missed some shapes in your analysis, you see the buttcheeks has curves even before the underwear ends? And now I'm actually laughing, because this whole discussion sounds so ridiculous.
- BeMuse
  +1 y
  Not much of one... Sure I know know a thing or two about anatomy. You kind of have to learn that to get a degree in biology... You also learn a few things winning tons of art awards but whatever. I showed you something in the middle. You don't like it and keep pushing extremes and then everyone wonders why girls have body image issues and become anorexic or over do it and become she hulks or get butt implants...
- whyisitso
  +1 y
  Well, I'm an artist. And I took a lot of biology courses. You should maybe then train your eyesight? You don't seem to be any good at this. And the pictures you put there are really photoshopped... good examples, for who? If a girl hasn't got naturally wide hips, she will never get an ass like the one you put there. I think these extremes are good to stick to, because they can never show the full truth and will always divide opinions. No girl will come here and be like "WHAT, a butt looking exactly like my butt hasn't got any votes!"
- BeMuse
  +1 y
  Yep they hand out the awards to people that aren't good. That's how it works...
- whyisitso
  +1 y
  Who hands you those awards? because if it wasn't in an art academy I really don't think it sounds at all persuasive. Also, you do not have to be good in drawing anatomy for getting a high school award from art classes.
- BeMuse
  +1 y
  I'm talking more about local art exhibits/competitions... But sure I also got the singular elementary school, middle school, and high school art art for 2D art all the way through school even though I wasn't interested in pursuing it as a career.
- whyisitso
  +1 y
  Haha... what a master. Your comment is so offensive. You claim the one in the second picture is overweight, really? Do you really think she is? She probably has a normal BMI and nothing to worry about with health. And the first one you tell to be a pancake? So who here is putting those false body images in girls heads?
- BeMuse
  +1 y
  You... You're creating polls of girls at either extreme and asking what guys like. That influences girls to chase certain body images when most women fall somewhere in the middle. Most will never be an ass model and be like the woman I posted. She's a professional model but she has toned legs and a butt that is larger than average but isn't exaggerated like the trends we see today with fitness models trying to make their ass and thighs giant. The angle on the first one is a photography trick with arching her back to make it look bigger. The second is a screen shot of a video that I cropped to just show her butt since that is what the question was about. There are plenty of hot women with different sizes and shapes of butts that are round, someone toned, with smooth toned legs. That's what I like and that might not be the same ass all men... It's not girls starving themselves to get a tiny butt or thigh gap and it's not girls getting disproportionate in the gym either.
- BeMuse
  +1 y
  As far as being offensive, well that's the nature of a question like this. You're judging them like meat and asking men to do the same. If a girl doesn't match your expectations she's going to get mad about it. No skin off my back. Everyone has their own task and range of what they think is attractive.
- BeMuse
  +1 y
  *taste
- whyisitso
  +1 y
  I don't think I asked you to judge them, I just asked which ones you like better. Big or small. That's not like you need to go and analyze every detail of the example pictures. And I don't personally have a butt like either of those girls, I just think it is wrong to go and spit shit out of your mouth even though you didn't find your dreambutt to be on this list.
- BeMuse
  +1 y
  what do you like better is a judgement call...
- BeMuse
  +1 y
  It's far worse for you to potentate trends that land girls in mental health clinics than for me to be honest.
- whyisitso
  +1 y
  The question I put here is a question that is already very widely discussed, and I think it is good to see that the trends aren't always very accurate. This is actually an open question to both girls and guys. And it was about choosing in general which you like better- big or small. Not about criticizing the butts on these pictures, I did not ask for you to analyze what you think is wrong with them. That's just offensive. Well, this is the internet, so just feel free to be a dick about it but don't try to put the blame on me.
- BeMuse
  +1 y
  I criticized your chooses not the girls. If you don't like that tough shit. Just because a bunch of other people are jumping off a cliff doesn't mean you should.
Malita55 Yoda
+1 y
Big. Obviously
1 0 0 0
Mexicoman101 Guru
+1 y
I have always thrown in with the big butt crowd since childhood. I could follow a big ass into the gates of hell.
1 0 1 0
Eryxx Guru
+1 y
A fit one.
1 0 0 0
Salmon4056 Yoda
+1 y
A medium toned high apple bottom butt.
1 0 0 0
- savvy1225
  +1 y
  Apple bottom jeans boots with the furrr
- Salmon4056
  +1 y
  @savvy1225 (with the fur) The whole club was lookin' at her😂
- savvy1225
  +1 y
  YESSS GIRL
Johnnie1000 Xper 7
+1 y
I can't choose because they both look so great. Can't I do one today and the other tomorrow?
1 0 0 0
metallicafan_22 Xper 5
+1 y
In between
1 0 1 0
IlyaTheImpaler Guru
+1 y
that's not exactly small lol
4 0 0 0
- whyisitso
  +1 y
  @BeMuse has a very different view on that one.
- IlyaTheImpaler
  +1 y
  Well he doesn't sound very bright and you presented three options but it seems he could only count to two and so he thought there's something unfair to women about there being two extremes and he must used all of his brain to analyze the perspective from his experience in drawing to choose one of those two etc. etc. I couldn't read all of his autistic rant, he could've just picked C. Simple preference isn't necessarily based on any offensive opinion, and his choice of words were offensive but he still tried to backpedal to make it into a criticism of your question lol. Best to ignore dumb people on here.
MarilynMansonsSlvt Yoda
+1 y
I have basically no ass and idc
xx
~ Mrs Manson
2 0 0 0
hellacray Guru
+1 y
The small butt in my opinion is big enough.

Although I really don't care for the size of butts.
3 0 0 0
NYCQuestions1976 Guru
+1 y
It's not necessarily about size:

Nice round ass = good.
Denim supported ass = bad.
3 1 0 0
Lance1965 Master
+1 y
I am not a butt person but I would prefer big anytime.
1 0 0 0
stormbreaker06 Guru
+1 y
depends on my mood.

sometimes i want mature booty, then young booty, tight young booty or big black booty... it just depends on my mood.

right now i want some young tight booty.
2 1 1 0
monkeynutts Guru
+1 y
Small man, I can't stand this big ass fad, its killing me.
2 0 0 0
Hispanic-Cool-Guy Master
+1 y
Big butt please.
1 0 0 0
Show More (12)