Does it look as if she's trying TOO hard?
I'm sure you prefer natural yaddayaddayadda, that's not the question. Millions of women around the world who wear makeup, cake faces or not, manage to find husbands and/or boyfriends.
Most Helpful Girl
It would look worse if a non-cute girl didn't wear makeup. At least she's trying and making the most of her appearance. Most girls do not have classically beautiful or stunningly exotic features which means most girls are avg and only a lucky few are actually really pretty. I wouldn't hold it against a girl for not being pretty. You would be surprised at the girls that are considered badd because without makeup and all the extras they are pretty average. So I support them wearing makeup and trying their best to look good, I think everyone should do that. An average girl with a decent body and good makeup is pretty. The unattractive girl with decent body and good makeup is average. Unless you're really deformed or not taking care of yourself you won't really be ugly, just not as pretty as naturally pretty girls. And that's OK. I think making an effort in your appearance makes everyone look better because it shows that you have some pride and makes you look more girlie