Most Helpful Guy
It depends on the social context, environmental conditions, and what else you're wearing them with.
If judging only the item by itself, I like them both. I like the texture and the design of the felt coat ...and it's gonna be in black? Even better. I like the zipper details of the shearling jacket and the fact that it's a shearling jacket! lol
I'm generally a practical-minded guy. I like the black felt coat more because it's more versatile. A black felt coat worn with tights or leggings is sensible, stylish, and classy.
The shearling jacket is more limited in the sense of when and where it can be worn. As such, it can be a rarity and when a girl wears it, she would command attention!
Choose wisely. =)