Most Helpful Girl
As long as you look well put together, it doesn't matter.
But the smokey look has a time and a place--so really it's about your timing. The smokey eye look is generally considered sexy, so, for instance, if y'all are going to the club and you wanna look put together for him, do the smokey eye and flirt with him throughout the night. Tease him a bit. Then when you do get home and you're alone together, y'all can have hot, p*rnstar like sex. I only say p*rnstar because of the smokey eye, it gives it the amateur p*rn feeling haha. Or if y'all have date night together and you just wanna switch up the look, try a smokey eye.
Guys on here may be all anti makeup, but at the same time they'll sit around complaining about variety yaddayadda.
As long as it looks good, guys don't care.