Most Helpful Guy
I like a girl who is in shape, but if it looks like who lift weight in the gym 4-5 days a week, then likely its a bit to much. Like others have said, I want a healthy but soft girl. Looking like you can kick my ass is not feminine.
More specifically I will admit that generally I have not been a fan of swimmer girls due to their broad shoulders. I actually dated a swimmer once who had such a body. She was attractive but I still would have preferred that her shoulders be a bit less broad and or her hips a bit wider, especially when looking at her from behind.
Regardless, I'd take a girl who has an extra 10 pounds of muscle over a girl who has an extra 10 pounds of fat any day. All I can say is its all about natural curves (not those created by fat).