Most Helpful Girl
They all suck..if you buy sh*tty quality.
Liquid can get crusty and cruchy and crinkle crumbs on your eye.
Or when it isn't pigmented...leave a transperant line on your eye.
Pencil can suck becaue it smears too much..every pencil I tried has always smeared.
As for gel liners...I find them a tad better that liquid atm...I have the loreal one and I like it...it can get a little dry though.