Both will have 10K gold with a blood red gem. (Garnet)
I found out a lot of students were going to Walmart to get their class ring, because the ring companies jack up the prices when you buy them through the school. And Walmart has the same ring styles.
Most Helpful Guy
Though it's of little consequence as with a face as pretty as yours not even a jeweler is likely to notice any ring you might be wearing, I think the first ring is more attractive. Congrats!