Good Idea or a Bad One?

Well, here it goes!

I'm a 16 year old highschool male interested in a girl I presume who is 1-2 years older than me. The only time I see this girl at any time is when I see her walking through the hallway by herself for a period of about 5-10 seconds (May I note this has been going on since the beginning of the school year now). Anyway, I'd like to talk to her but I don't got much to really say or throw out on the table in terms of flirting. The only thing I could really think to resort to is saying something out in a foreign language in Italian in a joking manner.

For example:

Me: *Walking up to her and tapping her on the shoulder*
- Sei troppo bella
- What?
- Na, I'm just messing with ya in Italian! I said I think you're really beautiful.

Would this be a good way to start with a complete stranger I like or no?

Opinions Please!
Seems Cute
Vote A
Seems Creepy
Vote B
Indifferent, please explain in comment below.
Vote C
Select age and gender to cast your vote:
Good Idea or a Bad One?
Add Opinion