Most Helpful Guys
I'd probably try scooping out the icing underneath the fly and about an inch around it and flipping the whole icing/fly blob into the trash. And then get another fork and eat the cake.
Most Helpful Girls
lol If I was mouthwatering enough for it and there was no more to be had, I would take a napkin and remove the fly and down the piece on my plate. I probably would not bat one eye as I devoured it. lol