He thinks it was wrong for the girl to jump back into the sinking ship and that she should have stayed on the lifeboat and leave without Jack. The character Jack himself even asked why she did that.
I think it was right because how can you possibly leave behind someone you love. in my opinion, if I can't get out of a situation with my fiance, I ain't going anywhere. I'm staying with my man till the end, even if it meant dying with him. My fiance still thinks differently and explained that if it came to worst, he would rather die knowing I'm safe than letting me die with him.
Most Helpful Guy
Personally I think Jack could have lived if he really wanted to. He had to die because he was covering for that dumb girls stupid actions.
I feel like they both could have lived if she stayed on the boat. For example. He would have found the piece of drift wood in the sea and stayed on it and lived instead of her since she wouldn't be there.
Instead this stupid girl did stupid things that got him killed while she got to live. I frankly saw Rose as the bad guy of the film. She got innocent people killed for her selfishness.
- Show AllShow Less
Most Helpful Girl
She was stupid because had she left, Jack probably would have lived. He died because of HER. Sad, but true.