I don't understand why people claim that "length isn't everything." Sex is more pleasurable the deeper the penis reaches. When a woman becomes fully aroused, her vagina stretches and expands. For the average woman, her vagina expands up to 7 inches when fully aroused. A good analogy for sex is similar to cleaning your ear with a Q-tip. You feel more sensation in your ear the deeper the Q-tip goes, but it can hurt if you hit your eardrum. As with sex, you feel more sensation the deeper the penis goes, but it can hurt if it rams the cervix too hard. Thus, to truly get the best out of sex, a penis with good length is required. Sure, girth is also important because a thicker penis can stimulate your walls better, but if your pussy isn't loose, then girth shouldn't be too much of any issue as long as the dick isn't too skinny. Besides, many women usually care more about girth when the dick is short. Many times, you often hear women say, "I don't mind a little dick unless it's thick," but rarely, if ever, hear a woman say that she primarily wants a short, but thick dick. Nonetheless though, to answer the question, I would prefer 8 inches. It's the size my fiancee has and seems like an almost perfect fit. As for dildos, I prefer 12 inches. It's not because I can take something 12 inches, but based on how vaginas works, it's unpredictable. When you're really aroused, you just never know how far it can expand, especially when you're in full control of what gets you off. A 12-inch dildo just happens to cover every base.
"I don't mind a little dick unless it's thick, but rarely, if ever, hear a woman say that she primarily wants a short, but thick dick." I'm only six and a half long and five and a half circumference, so I fail both those categories! :( [cries] Some women have say I'm really good at oral sex. But hell, I guess I had no other choice but to be!
@MCheetah: You have an average size though. 6.5 inches is close to 7 inches, which is the average depth of a fully aroused vagina. You should be long enough to reach the average girl's G-spot. If not, certain positions can definitely help. 5.5 inches of girth is pretty good. That's like toilet paper roll size around, right, or am I wrong? If so, then it's not too thick to where you completely stretch her out and cause pain, but also not too skinny to where you can't feel anything when she's wet. Combine with the fact that you're willing to eat the pussy and I would say you're probably a good pleaser!
7+ hurts. 4– is not enough. I've never been with a 5/6 but i think that would be perfect
I wouldn't consider a 6 mediocre. He’s prob be perfect
Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions
What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!6 inches is good and the question was the most comfortable... i'm wowed by a 10 incher but it can be difficult dealing with a massive cock.
Not a straight woman. you invited the wrong one.
C, D, and E for me would be best
Sexual Relationships 
Sexual Health 
Superb Opinion