Ass size or ass shape?

What is more important? The size of the ass or the shape of it? Guys, what would you rate my size and shape? Ps. first photo is like 5 months ago and 2nd photo is about a month.
Ass size or ass shape?
Ass size or ass shape?
2 36

Superb Opinion

  • Looks like you've fallen into this 'booty' fashion trap. Pic A is much more attractive.
    I wish more people thought things like tattoos and large weight gains etc - especially at the moment with SARS-COV2. Yes, it might look ball achingly fashionable now, but fashions change (quickly), tattoos and stretchmarks stay forever (or both can be removed but are horrendously expensive to do so).
    The answer to your question is shape. Wanting a 'tight ass' has always been desirable for men and for women. The first place that women's bodies store fat is on their ass, hips and thighs, for men it's the love handles and gut. If guys all of a sudden thought it looked cool to rock a dad bod, would you be thinking, 'Yea, looks great I love all that fat slappin' on me' or would you be thinking 'WTF?' and sticking with the 6 pack/fit/healthy dudes?
    For some reason, some lazy fucker (Kim Kardashian, probably) thought that having a firm arse like a model or supermodel was too much like hard work (You find me a high end model who has a 'booty' - aka a fat arse, and I'll find you a model with no work or who's retired) so she's gone to the extreme of having ribs removed, fat pumped into her arse from other areas of her body, wearing corsets like they used to a hundred plus years ago, and telling everyone who was slim, athletic and healthy looking that they are 'ugly'. This is bullshit on a par with 'Why not have a celebrity TV show host be the President? What could possibly go wrong...'
    Now there is a global pandemic. If you have a high BMI, you are 4 times more likely to and up in intensive care. More and more young people are getting infected and the ENTIRE medical community is telling everyone to get off their (fat) ass, and get into shape. The same shape that all the successful supermodels have always been in - lean and toned. You think Kim K can 'reverse' what she's done to her body? Not even with her bank balance. Google the photos of her that haven't been Photoshopped and tell me you want an ass that looks like cottage cheese squeezed into a condom...

Most Helpful Guy

  • Why can't I just love whatever she has, the way she has it, and smile? I HONESTLY cannot say, that I have a preference!!
    I am TOTALLY a 'Butt guy' and ADORE women's soft round bottoms!!
    But sometimes, I like the tight, firm little ones, when I am dating an athlete, and into some sport! But other times, when dating another, I love her soft, sensually round, and soft bottom!! Strangely, the ones with the most wonderful, full, soft bottoms, seem to love spanking play, to excite her!! Coincidence?

Most Helpful Girls

  • Both are important but I think shape matters more. I'd rather have a small toned butt than a big saggy butt.

  • Shape and size. Both are important for a fabulous bum

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls & Guys Said

7 184
  • Both shape and size! A nice round butt can make me forget what I was doing. 🥰

  • I'm much more about shape. High, round bubble butts forever.

  • I would say shape... because you can have a big booty but if its not in shape then what is the whole point. Oh and damn that second pic... yeah it would do girl. :-)

  • Just be fit. What's this obsession on form absent function? You move well, function well, dance well, be energetic, sociable. That's hot. Who cares about the measurements of your ass? And what is that mostly -- fat or muscle in the glutes?

    • As for rate, I dunno. Looks awesome both pics. I don't know about this size or shape stuff. I like proportional though. Both look in proportion. I don't like girls with massive lower body and small upper in a similar way I don't think it looks cool for a guy to have massive upper body and chicken legs. I like it all to be sort of balanced.

  • Your booty is stunning. Shape forever.

  • Shape 100%. And yours is definitely shapely. I'd go so far as to say ideal - round, plump (in a good way), smooth and gorgeous. And your bod looks well proportioned.
    I don't like the thicc look with gigantic asses and thunder thighs. They look out of proportion, like cartoon caricatures.

  • both are important. Flat asses are a turn off. Toned ones are nice. I'm not expecting a muscular ass, but hitting the weights definitely helps. Your butt is nice in both pictures

  • Damn Jane, your ass is so nice...
    Your size & ass “go to 11”

    https://www.youtube.com/embed/4xgx4k83zzc
    • *Your size & shape “go to 11”

    • @janefryer_1998, 179 guys have replied so far... how does it feel for your ass to be getting so much attention/love?

  • Both are important but shape first size second (and if you have a big shapely ass even better).

  • I prefer a smaller ass but it's not a deal breaker. Your behind looks like it could entice many young men.

  • I like both giving u a high 5 on each cheek

  • Shape is way more inportant to me. Things I think the perfect ass has are. ..
    --Nice round cheeks
    --Those 2 dimples above the ass
    --Divots on the lower inside of each buttcheek
    --a clear crease of were ass stops and thighs start, or on a very petite woman those lower divot basiclly do this
    --small enough that the ass itself dosent obstruct the view of the thought gap.

    May sound like a lot of things have to happen at once and I dont like many butts, but I see all these fairly common.

    Not to sound like a perv but we dont see much of your ass un the pics. I would still rate it a 8 out of 10 cause what I do see I like, very nice ass.

    Bonus
    Kind of off topic but u recently decided I like tall women cause I figure all of her is bigger right? So she is petite but also bigger. Seems like the perfect way to get shape and size.
    --

  • Shape

    10/10

    Second picture is lovely

    • Is your profile pic you? Just curious its such a tease

    • It is yes but we won't talk about it here.

    • Where do we talk about it 🤔

  • I think for some girls there is a benefit to one and a benefit to the other.

    It all depends on the shape of your butt and the size of your butt.

    I would think that the more skinny you butt is the more featured the shape and the bigger your butt is the more that the shape does not matter.

    But both the shape and the size of the butt can be equally attractive

  • The shape of a girl's ass is most important I my eyes, though as I prefer a smalker, slimmer size I guess "size" is also relevant
    You look great in both pics you've attached, the 1st one is especially hottt !

  • Definitely ass shape. I couldn't care less if your ass is small, but I do want it to be shaped well.

  • Shape definitely. I give an 8/10

  • shape and yours is perfect

  • I honestly dont mind, for me it's the actual woman's personality that determines my attraction, and that if her ass is whatever shape/size it is i would find it hot

  • Not an assman myself, more into a good chest and cleavage.

    But from my assman friends, it's more the shape of the hips than the form itself, that gets their blood pumping.

  • Show More (171)