Should This Girl be Upset Because After Having Sex, She Realized it wasn't with Her Boyfriend?

Abigail took a surprise peen in her unwitting sniz
Abigail took a surprise peen in her unwitting sniz
VOTE BELOW!

Abigail Finney thought she was having sex with her boyfriend.

In his dorm room at Purdue University in West Lafayette, Indiana, Finney had fallen asleep with him cuddling beside her in his loft bed. Elsewhere in the same room, three of her boyfriend’s buddies were crashed on a futon after a casual night that involved a lot of video games and a little drinking, although Finney says she stayed sober.

Later, in a hazy half-awake state, Finney felt a hand from behind fondling her over her t-shirt. Keeping quiet so as not to awake the others in the dark room, she allowed further groping from the man in bed with her, which led to brief intercourse, all the while with her back to him.

The sex ended when Finney said she had to go to the bathroom — and only after she returned, as she started to climb back into the loft, did she realize the man in bed with her wasn’t her boyfriend, but rather one of his friends.

“I remember him grinning at me. It was a freaky image,” Finney told BuzzFeed in a recent article. “I was just kind of — I was frantic. I didn’t know what was going on.”

Her report of the incident eventually led to a rape charge against Donald Grant Ward, who was acquitted earlier this year of any wrongdoing in the February 2017 encounter, reports the Lafayette Journal & Courier.

Under Indiana law that defines rape as an act of aggression or involving an unwilling victim, Ward can’t be convicted just because Finney, who consented to the sex, believed he was someone other than who she thought he was, Ward’s attorney Kirk Freeman told TV station WLFI.

“Lots of women this weekend are going to have sex with Navy Seals, going to have sex with football heroes, going to have sex with guys that rescue kittens from the middle of the interstate, and are going to have sex with men who tell them, ‘I love you,’ and, ‘I’m ready for a commitment,'” Freeman said. “Just because they are lying doesn’t make it rape.”
Should This Girl be Upset Because After Having Sex, She Realized it wasnt with Her Boyfriend?
So upset! Wrong peen! What a nightmare! :(
Vote A
Should This Girl be Upset Because After Having Sex, She Realized it wasnt with Her Boyfriend?
Meh. No big deal. Peen is peen. Time to move on! :)
Vote B
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
Girl Guy
0 1

Most Helpful Girls

  • This is a fucking weird story. I mean where was her boyfriend? didn't she feel it when he slipped out of bed? and another guy joined in. why would the accused slip in bed with her in the first place? And Couldn’t she sense that this is not her boyfriend.

    • If you google this story you can learn more details. I think the boyfriend left his room and went to her room and fell asleep. She didn't realize this and she fell asleep in her boyfriend's loft. The boyfriend's buddies were playing video games and at some point, one of them snuck up into the loft and started spooning with young Abigail. Things advanced and she didn't stop him when he slipped his stiffened peen into her sleepy, moist sniz because she thought it was her boyfriend. It was only after he deposited his man nectar that she went to the bathroom and upon her return, she saw that dude creepily grinning at her and she realized that she just took a creamy load from an imposter peen :(

    • Jesus! This is one messed up and unusual story. I guess he was acquitted because the incident doesn’t fall into any category. Like other stories of rape such as date rape , or an unconscious woman, or kidnapping. Its like a misunderstanding or so...

  • Yes, I view that as rape. She didn’t consent to this man and the risk of disease he carried. She consented to her boyfriend, and him alone.

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls & Guys Said

5 26
  • I find it hard to believe she didn't know. Did they have exactly the same size penis and technique? If you accidentally put the wrong coat on you instinctively feel its not right and dicks just the same

    • I just posted an interview with her in my update. It was a new boyfriend and maybe her young sniz hadn't totally become accustomed to the feel of his engorged peen? Also, it sounds like she was kind of out of it.

  • I call bullshit on the whole story, sounds like she cheated and just didn't want to own up to it.

    • Nah. That's ridiculous. Did you watch the video?

    • Nope, but I've read so many stories like this, like a journalist who said she was raped while at a party, where she got drunk and consented to sex, then continued to see the guy who "raped her" even though she was already in a relationship. I've heard the matress girl story were she was trying to get into a relationship with the guy but because he didn't want a relationship she decided he raped her even though she was proven to be lying. This sounds an awful lot like those incidents.

    • How 'bout watching the video? Kinda hard to form an opinion with your head buried in the sand.

    • Show All
  • Faith in humanity lost, man.
    Just listen to that piece of shit attorney, I'm seriously surprised people like that aren't being found hanged on their own intestines more often.

    • Yeah. And if it happened to his wife or daughter, I'm sure he'd be totally kewl with it.

  • The problem is mainly the laws interpretation of the event, not the event itself.

    US laws are pretty out of date, and this sort of thing is incredibly hard to bring to court. Bet she wishes she'd just lied, and said he forced himself onto her.

    • As a woman i can tell u its difficult to lie in such cases. Because u will be interrogated. And asked many times “tell us exactly what happened?”. And if u weren’t consistent u wouldn’t be taken seriously. She should tell them exactly how he forced himself on her. And how did she fight back.

  • It depends on the truth of the story
    IF indeed the story is accurate and can be proven... THEN perhaps it could be classified as rape to a degree (even though she didn't recognize at first)
    BUT STILL
    I bring into question how she didn't recognize? so im unsure

    However, women have been known to use these accusations as a way to ruin a mans image. This is especially prevalent in the "metoo" era where a women's word should be accepted a fact without any sort of backing...
    This has created a great deal of false information
    for example the "rape culture" of college campuses.. which is almost non existent (at least to the degree they claim... its nowhere near 1 to 5... but closer to 1 in 1000)

    I understand making such statements puts me out as being a "sexist" or "misogynist"
    but its simply the truth

    rape is rape
    and if it is rape, then the man should suffer the consequences
    but lets not assume the woman is always truthful

    I dealt with a similar case in college where a girl reported me because I wouldn't date her
    It was embarrassing, destroyed many of my friendships.. ruined my image on campus
    eventually they found out she was lying (thanks to another questionable case she created)
    Things like this happen
    and many of these "equality" movements are often weaponized for personal gain

    • If you read the article and watch the video, you will learn that this situation was not considered a crime in her state. And you got in trouble for NOT dating a girl? lol. What? And then when it was understood that you did date her, everything was fine? I don't understand.

    • Haha Yes, I read the entire thing and I understand he didn't get into trouble. I was just speaking generally.. not really taking Indiana law into consideration. In terms of my situation the girl wanted to date me, we were friends.. we hung out a decent amount (I had several female friends). However... I just wasn't interested in dating her.. she wasn't my type. She was angry about the whole thing and accused me sexually assaulting her the school of course took the situation very clearly there was threats of expulsion and legal issues... I was interrogated by the campus police.. my RD.. along with other school officials on several occasions. ETC in the end, they couldnt prove it.. and decided the best course of action was that I avoid her (thankfully for me.. I was scared to death) ends up at the same time she was accusing her BOYFRIEND... of "hacking" into her phone... and spreading private information or something? (I can't remember the specifics... but it was quite ridiculous) which I think proved to people to the authorities she wasn't the most trustworthy case none the less I went to school for another 3 years and STILL... my image was tarnished by the time I graduated some people I had known before.. had no interest in speaking to me she went out of her way to spread the BS I lost a lot of good friends

    • Oh ok. That explanation clears things up a bit. Your first attempt left too many details out and it didn't make sense. :)

    • Show All
  • While that story is kinda messed up, I dont know if i would go as far as to charge or attempt to charge the guy with rape because, i thought that he was my boyfriend

  • Seriously? I hope those 16 guys who voted B are trolling, because that is SO wrong.

    Not only should she be upset, her boyfriend should have kicked the living crap outta the guy

  • Yes

    i would be upset too

  • Dude was at fault. He obviously knew what he was doing but did she really not know? She didn't even turn around to look when she knew other drunk people were in the room?

  • I find it very difficult to believe she didn't know it wasn't her boyfriend.

  • Ooops, I did it again ! LOL

  • I think sex by deception is clearly rape.

  • Umm, am I the only wondering where her boyfriend went? Has anyone found him?

    • In the video, they indicate she still had the same boyfriend at the time of the interview.

  • Next time I bring home a nice young woman from the bar, I will accuse her of rape when she says "I have never done this before" when she's clearly a hoe. I consented to sex with a woman who really has never done that before.

    • A "nice" girl would never come home with you and no jury in the country would ever believe you thought the young lady in question wasn't a ho. lol.

    • They're all nice.

  • If she doesn't know the difference between the two cocks, then what's the diff?

  • seems like rape to me

  • It was rape. She didn't have regret afterwards. She didn't want it with the guy who was doing it. It doesn't matter if ahe didn't know at the time.

  • The girl doesn't need to be upset coz she wasn't at fault, infact the guy knew what he was doing and took advantage of whole situation

    • She doesn't feel at fault. She feels violated.

    • She should put a rape charge against him and i fully support it

    • She did. I just added a video in my update.

  • What a slut. I hope her boyfriend dumped her ass and isn't a willing cuck.

    • According to the video, he was still her boyfriend at the time of the interview.

    • Oh my. How sick! She fucked his friend and its public asf. He must have a serious humiliation fetish thats just wrong. Its only a matter of time before she has sex in the dark and its another one of his friends. Smh.

    • lol.

  • Unless she was date raped the answer is no you would still have to be totally shit faced not to realize that she was looking to get fucked and now that's her excuse to not making it look bad

  • Show More (11)