Is asking a girl what size she prefers inappropriate when starting to date?

I have been talking to this girl and she mentioned her sexual history before. She had talked at length about how unsatisfied she's been sexually and even went as far to say she broke up with a guy over his penis size.
I randomly asked her what is too small for her and I have yet to hear back. I'm decent sized, but I'm unsure now that she's mentioned how small her ex was.
It's a fair question
Vote A
I shouldn't have asked
Vote B
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
Girl Guy
0 0

Superb Opinion

  • I can answer it right now and save you the trouble: she more than likely doesn't care. This obsession some men have over their penis size comes from watching way too much porn and not listening enough to what actual women (who aren't getting paid to spew out a bunch of BS in regards to what they like sexually) want. The vast majority of women are not physically/visually attracted to penises. Don't get me wrong, there are parts of the male body women go crazy over, but the penis isn't one of them. Women do love a man who knows how to use his penis right during sex, but that has little to nothing to do with the actual penis size. In fact, if a penis is too big it can actually make sex more painful and less enjoyable.

    • Just the way she talked about the one ex, she seemed she cared a bit. I get what you're saying. I appreciate it

Most Helpful Girl

  • It wasn’t just his size that was the problem. He didn’t know how to use it.

    • Thanks for the MHO. :)

Most Helpful Guys

  • Ordinarily, it's not something I'd ask, but if she's openly told you she broke up with a guy over it, it's probably better to hash it out now, so you don't waste time.

  • It's fair because of what she was talking about. Generally it's not a goid thing to ask.

    • It's been some time since she told me about this.

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls & Guys Said

1 3
  • You shouldn’t have asked

  • Dude, she wants BBC. I met them white girls.
    Do I actually have that or no?
    Don't ask, don't tell.👌

  • I would of stopped talking to her immediately

  • Normally I would say no, but since you had a talk about it and she has a strong opinion on the size, I do think its is an ok question to sort out before you start dating for real.

    • Even though she mentioned this a while ago? We just haven't had sex yet and it's getting serious

    • yes, she said she dumped a guy because of size, I see why you would be concerned, and she can just be honest and say what is too small.

    • Do you think she'll be upset with me for asking? Plus, what if I'm not as big as she wants?

    • Show All