What if you were stuck on a deserted island with a girl?

Your boat sank very suddenly and a guy and a girl were the only ones to get off before it sank. Trouble is it happened so fast that both of you were only able to get off because you didn't take the time to get dressed and you jumped into the water in your underwear. The girl was wearing a thong and a push up bra, and the guy his Fruit of the Loom tightie whities. So you got to the island and were there for a week before a rescue party arrived to find you.
The rescue party locates you and are surprised to find you were wearing nothing but each other's underwear.
Your job is to think up a back story as to why you were wearing each other's underwear when you were found. He in the thong and bra and her in the tightie whities.
Bonus, if you were one of the two found, what would you say when you were surprised by them arriving and seeing you?
0 2

Most Helpful Girls

  • Some tattered looking guy came out of the brush with a camera and said we were on a reality show and the challenge was to see if you could beat other contestants on how long it takes you to switch clothing. So we did and were told to wait for the next contestants. So we waited and waited and then the rescue people showed up and we said, after looking at all the clothes they had on, we said "wooo hooo, we are going to win this hands, or pants, down! They mumbled something like, "Let's forget these two and take the Jap soldiers back, the ones that think the war is still on. We'll get more press with them than with these two weirdos." And that's the last we saw of them. Now that I think about it their show sounded fake.

    What if you were stuck on a deserted island with a girl?
  • "Don't pick Dare with him."

    "I had to show him who is in charge and this is the closest I had to pants"

    "Look there are no pads out here and I certainly wasn't going to mess up MY underwear"

    "Welcome to Paradise Fashion Week"

    "Look... it's exactly what it looks like. Can you just get us out of here?"


    Just take your pick of those 😊

    • Don't pick dare with him? I assume you mean you were playing truth or dare?

    • Yep!

Most Helpful Guys

  • Okay here's what happened. When they first got to shore on the island the guy went exploring for food. He came across a berry patch with dark red berries. While he was picking them his tighty whiteys got stained dark red. Meanwhile the woman was wearing her thong and bra but they were both white. She got her period and of course had no pads or tampons. Seeing her situation the guy offered her the berry-stained tighty whiteys and accepted her thong for him to wear, offering him some degree of support as he made his way through the jungle gathering food. It also occurred to him that if he wore her bra he could use it to hold berries in the cups, allowing him to bring back more in one trip to their camp on the beach.

    • That would be looked at with a laugh. If you were both stained red then why exchange shorts" The berries in the bra reminds me of girls who are not even an A cup.

    • Gosh Daniela I thought it was a plausible scenario considering the already unlikely parameters of your hypothetical. But you're right, after one trip into the berry patch wearing the thong it would have gotten stained dark red as well. So the woman could just as well have worn it during her period anyway. But assuming she had larger size breasts I think the cups of her bra would have held more berries than you think. They didn't have a basket for the guy to carry the berries. His chest was stained dark red though.

    • I don't think you would be going into any berry bushes as they all have some nice thorns. With nothing on but underwear you would come out of there in tatters.

    • Show All
  • What if you were stuck on a deserted island with a girl?

    As they say shit happens & from time to time ships do sink & if I’m lucky to get stuck on a deserted island hopefully it’s with someone as radiant & wonderful such as you. If the island is beautiful I wouldn’t really want to get rescued & if the island is anything like Gilligan’s island happily ever after it would be. As for being rescued in my tighty whities I would tell everyone you still my drawers & as for me wearing your thong I’ll let you come up with a story on that one.

    • I'll be waiting for it.

    • All in good time, all in good time.

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls & Guys Said

2 13
  • "She told me that girls have a better chance of being rescued so I stole her undies and she's been chasing me around the island ever since. Thank god you got here because she almost caught me."

  • I don't get it, why should we wear each other's underwear?
    Wouldn't it be more productive to make a shelter, find food and water?

    • You didn't read the question all the way through.

  • she said if we exchanged clothes she'd finally have sex with me before we died. she's crazy, get me outta here!

    • I would think the sex would be happening before the exchange was complete.

    • nah, she was making me wear it for a few days so it would be easier to pretend i was a woman

  • I'd say, "Thank you for finding us so quickly. We were just rehearsing a play we wrote together where a man and a women undergo sex change surgery. We're just about to start act three where the surgery has been completed and the couple are getting comfortable with their new bodies. Won't you please sit and enjoy the remainder of the show?"

    • They would say, "Er, sorry we can't stay for the show but we were on our way to another island and took a wrong turn. We'll drop back by on our way back." and that would be the last the happy couple would see of them.

    • Touché. 😂

  • "It's simply A- MAZ-ing how dark it gets at night. This morning we woke up found we grabbed the wrong undies but found it felt kind of nice, so no problem. Whatever we grab, we wear."

    • Hmm, so if she grabbed your dick?

    • She could wear it (out) for a few minutes, sure. What else is there to do?

  • People not situation every one of them end up having sex

    • Come on, you can think of a better story than that.

    • Yes of course I can with you in it. But you are always so serious I dont want to rock the boat with you and having you think I am just one of these crazy sexual GAGGERS

    • I'm sorry it was voice command error I kind of messed up the first post and sent it to fast before reading it

    • Show All
  • You need to write more erotic stories. I almost sprang a leak in my ship reading this post. LITIROTICAdotCOM

  • Probably doing some role playing since they had nothing else going on after a week but trying to survive, maybe he was getting tired of being the hunter gatherer all week and said he would gladly switch with her and she said sure if you wear my underwear

    • Well they certainly couldn't say "If you were in my shoes..." If she said "If you were in my shorts" he would say "Would love to be"

    • Very true 😊

  • I would say that when we saw the rescue boat coming to pick us up @Daniela1982 told me we should wear each other's underwear to confuse them. So i agreed and afterwards we didn't want to give back each other's underwear because she liked the room and i looked pretty. 😎

  • sounds like a best case scenario

  • I'm sure we could come up with something.

  • You had a good question until the switch. So , you must wear thong undies?

    • The guy would wind up wearing them. Your mission is to figure out why they switched and how they explained it to their rescuers.

    • I don't think I would ever wear women's thong undies.

  • Tell them my chest was getting cold so she let me use her bra. I needed the thong to hold my cock down while worked. Just disappointed they found us so fast. We were in heaven fucking so much.

  • Interesting one! I like that idea 😁

  • Hope she know how to hunt and survive

    • You didn't read the question all the way through either did you?